Women's College Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Qual Health Res. 2013 Sep;23(9):1228-39. doi: 10.1177/1049732313502396. Epub 2013 Aug 9.
Despite the increasing implementation of standardized rape kits across jurisdictions, the medico-legal findings generated by these tools are often not related to positive criminal justice outcomes. Given that there has been no global investigation of the factors that might impede their successful use in cases of sexual assault, we conducted a review of relevant scholarly and "grey" literature from industrialized and less-developed regions. One key theme to emerge from the analysis concerned certain problematic practices and behaviors of professional groups involved in the various stages of the post-sexual assault process. We found that a lack of competence in handling sexual assault cases, contempt for women who have been victimized, and corruption among some forensic examiners, police, scientists, and legal personnel often have shaped the collection, processing, analysis, and use of medico-legal evidence. We discuss recent initiatives and future directions for research that might serve to address these issues.
尽管在司法管辖区内越来越多地实施标准化的强奸工具包,但这些工具生成的医学法律调查结果往往与积极的刑事司法结果无关。鉴于尚未对可能妨碍其在性侵犯案件中成功使用的因素进行全球调查,我们对来自工业化和欠发达地区的相关学术和“灰色”文献进行了回顾。分析中出现的一个关键主题涉及参与性侵犯后各个阶段的专业群体的某些有问题的做法和行为。我们发现,缺乏处理性侵犯案件的能力、对受害妇女的蔑视以及一些法医检查人员、警察、科学家和法律人员中的腐败现象,往往影响了医学法律证据的收集、处理、分析和使用。我们讨论了可能有助于解决这些问题的最新举措和未来研究方向。