Yonkers Kimberly A, Howell Heather B, Gotman Nathan, Rounsaville Bruce J
Department of Psychiatry, Yale School of Medicine, Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA ; Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, Yale School of Medicine, Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA.
J Subst Use. 2011 Oct 1;16(5):372-389. doi: 10.3109/14659891003721133.
Many factors comprise a patient's decision to disclose use of drugs. Pregnant women may report drug use because they would like help with their addiction but the stigma associated with drug use may dampen their willingness to disclose. Knowledge about the accuracy of self-reported drug use as compared to urine toxicology screens can assist clinicians in the management of substance use in pregnancy.
We compared the urine toxicology screens and self-reported use of marijuana or cocaine for 168 women enrolled in an integrated obstetrical/substance abuse treatment program. We stratified by various periods of self-reported use and Cohen's kappa to measure overall agreement between self-report and toxicology tests.
Most women with a positive toxicology screen reported use in the past 28 days (78% for marijuana, 86% for cocaine). However, many women reported their most recent use to be outside of the assays' detection window (14% for marijuana, 57% for cocaine). We did not find differences in self-report for women with positive urine between Whites and non-Whites (p = 1.00). Agreement over the previous month was good (Kappa = 0.74 and 0.70 for marijuana and cocaine, respectively.).
A question about use of marijuana or cocaine during the preceding month rather than the prior few days may be a better indicator of use.
患者决定披露药物使用情况受多种因素影响。孕妇可能会报告药物使用情况,因为她们希望获得成瘾方面的帮助,但与药物使用相关的耻辱感可能会削弱她们披露的意愿。了解自我报告的药物使用情况与尿液毒理学筛查结果的准确性,有助于临床医生管理孕期药物使用问题。
我们对参加综合产科/药物滥用治疗项目的168名女性的尿液毒理学筛查结果与自我报告的大麻或可卡因使用情况进行了比较。我们根据自我报告的不同使用时间段进行分层,并使用科恩kappa系数来衡量自我报告与毒理学检测之间的总体一致性。
大多数毒理学筛查呈阳性的女性报告在过去28天内有使用情况(大麻为78%,可卡因为86%)。然而,许多女性报告她们最近一次使用是在检测窗口期之外(大麻为14%,可卡因为5�%)。我们发现尿液呈阳性的女性中,白人和非白人在自我报告方面没有差异(p = 1.00)。上个月的一致性良好(大麻和可卡因的kappa系数分别为0.74和0.70)。
询问前一个月而非前几天的大麻或可卡因使用情况,可能是更好的使用指标。