Department of Family Medicine, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MN, Canada.
BMC Med Educ. 2013 Aug 23;13:112. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-13-112.
Medical students' attitudes and beliefs about homeless people may be shaped by the attitudes of their teachers and one of the most common sites for learning about homeless patients is the emergency department. The objective of this study was to determine if medical students in the preclinical and clinical years and emergency medicine faculty and residents have different attitudes and beliefs about homeless people.
The Health Professional Attitudes Toward the Homeless Inventory (HPATHI), was administered to all medical students, and emergency medicine physicians and residents at a large academic health sciences center in Canada. The HPATHI examines attitudes, interest and confidence on a 5-point Likert scale. Differences among groups were examined using the Kruskal Wallis test and Pearson's chi-square test.
The HPATHI was completed by 371 individuals, for an overall response rate of 55%. Analysis of dichotomized median and percentage results revealed 5/18 statements were significant by both methods. On the attitudes subscales physicians and residents as a group were more negative for 2/9 statements and on the confidence subscale more positive for 1/4 statements. The interest subscale achieved overall statistical significance with decreased positive responses among physicians and residents compared to medical students in 2/5 statements.
This study revealed divergences in attitudes, interests and beliefs among medical students and emergency medicine physicians and residents. We offer strategies for training interventions and systemic support of emergency faculty. Emergency medicine physicians can examine their role in the development of medical students through both formal and informal teaching in the emergency department.
医学生对无家可归者的态度和信念可能受到其教师态度的影响,而了解无家可归患者的最常见场所之一是急诊科。本研究的目的是确定临床前和临床医学生以及急诊医学教师和住院医师对无家可归者是否具有不同的态度和信念。
在加拿大一所大型学术卫生科学中心,向所有医学生以及急诊医学医师和住院医师发放了卫生专业人员对无家可归者态度量表(HPATHI)。HPATHI 采用 5 点 Likert 量表评估态度、兴趣和信心。使用 Kruskal-Wallis 检验和 Pearson's chi-square 检验比较组间差异。
共有 371 人完成了 HPATHI,总体回复率为 55%。对二分中位数和百分比结果的分析表明,两种方法均有 5/18 项陈述具有统计学意义。在态度子量表上,医生和住院医师群体在 9/2 项陈述上更为消极,而在信心子量表上在 4/1 项陈述上更为积极。兴趣子量表总体上具有统计学意义,与医学生相比,医生和住院医师在 5/2 项陈述中表现出的积极反应减少。
本研究揭示了医学生和急诊医学医师和住院医师之间在态度、兴趣和信念方面的差异。我们为培训干预和急诊教师的系统支持提供了策略。急诊医师可以通过在急诊科进行正式和非正式教学来审视他们在医学生发展中的作用。