de Haan Inken Friederike, Ciesielski Robert, Nitsche Tobias, Koos Bernd
Department of Orthodontics, University Hospital of Schleswig-Holstein, Campus Kiel, Arnold-Heller-Str. 3, Haus 26, 24105, Kiel, Germany.
J Orofac Orthop. 2013 Sep;74(5):362-9. doi: 10.1007/s00056-013-0161-0. Epub 2013 Aug 23.
Multidisciplinary treatment of skeletal malocclusion by orthognathic surgery in addition to orthodontics is a routine strategy believed to offer good functional and esthetic outcomes. Postoperative relapse is, however, a problem. The present study was conducted to analyze the stability of outcomes achieved by surgical treatment of skeletal class III patients in terms of the rate and extent of relapses.
A total of 30 patients who had undergone orthodontic treatment combined with orthognathic surgery were included. The primary inclusion criterion was a skeletal class III treated by mandibular setback (Obwegeser/Dal Pont) surgery alone or combined with maxillary advancement (Le Fort I) surgery. Analysis was based on one preoperative and two postoperative cephalograms per patient.
We observed relapse (defined, in accordance with Proffit, as changes >2 mm or 2°) at a rate of 24% after bimaxillary procedures, compared to a lower rate of 21% after mandibular setback procedures only. The relapse rate was 21% among patients who had undergone upper-jaw surgery versus 27% among those who had undergone lower-jaw surgery, which was statistically significant.
The majority of patients exhibited stable treatment outcomes. Maxillary advancement procedures were found to be less susceptible to relapse-resulting in more stable outcomes-and mandibular setback distances correlated positively with the degree of the relapse. No statistically significant differences were observed between the procedures conducted in both jaws versus in the lower jaw only, or in the extent of upper-jaw repositioning.
除正畸治疗外,通过正颌手术对骨骼性错牙合畸形进行多学科治疗是一种常规策略,被认为能带来良好的功能和美学效果。然而,术后复发是一个问题。本研究旨在分析骨骼Ⅲ类患者手术治疗效果的稳定性,包括复发率和复发程度。
总共纳入30例接受正畸治疗联合正颌手术的患者。主要纳入标准是仅通过下颌后缩(Obwegeser/Dal Pont)手术或联合上颌前徙(Le Fort Ⅰ)手术治疗的骨骼Ⅲ类患者。分析基于每位患者一张术前头颅侧位片和两张术后头颅侧位片。
我们观察到,双颌手术术后的复发率(根据Proffit的定义,变化>2 mm或2°)为24%,而下颌后缩手术单独进行时复发率较低,为21%。接受上颌手术的患者复发率为21%,而接受下颌手术的患者复发率为27%,具有统计学意义。
大多数患者表现出稳定的治疗效果。发现上颌前徙手术较不易复发,从而产生更稳定的效果,且下颌后缩距离与复发程度呈正相关。在双颌手术与仅下颌手术之间,或在上颌重新定位的程度方面,未观察到统计学上的显著差异。