Cawley Derek T, Alexander Michael, Morris Seamus
Department of Trauma and Orthopedic Surgery, Adelaide and Meath Hospital, Tallaght, Dublin 24, Ireland,
Eur Spine J. 2014 Feb;23(2):320-7. doi: 10.1007/s00586-013-2962-7. Epub 2013 Aug 22.
Assessment of the integrity of the multifidus muscles and corresponding nerve roots, post-open (OSS) versus minimally invasive spinal surgery (MISS) for lumbar spine fractures.
We investigated the first six patients undergoing MISS in our institution and age- and sex-matched them with 6 random patients who previously had OSS. All had a similar lumbar fracture configuration without evidence of spinal cord injury. All were assessed using ultrasound muscle quantification and electromyographic studies at a minimum of 6 months post-operatively. Mean cross-sectional area (CSA) was measured at sequential levels within and adjacent to the operative field. Concentric needle electromyography was performed at instrumented and adjacent non-instrumented levels in each patient.
Mean CSA across all lumbar multifidus muscles was 4.29 cm(2) in the MISS group, 2.26 cm(2) for OSS (p = 0.08). At the instrumented levels, mean CSA was 4.21 cm(2) for MISS and 2.03 cm(2) for OSS (p = 0.12). At non-instrumented adjacent levels, mean CSA was 4.46 cm(2) in the MISS group, 2.87 cm(2) for OSS (p = 0.05). Electromyography at non-instrumented adjacent levels demonstrated nerve function within normal limits in 5/6 levels in the MISS group compared to 1/6 levels in the OSS (p = 0.03). Instrumented levels demonstrated nerve function within normal limits in 5/12 levels in the MISS group compared with 4/12 in the OSS group, including moderate-severe denervation at 5 levels in the OSS group (p = 0.15).
Posterior instrumented MISS demonstrates a significantly superior preservation of the medial branch of the posterior ramus of the spinal nerve and less muscle atrophy, particularly at adjacent levels when compared to OSS.
评估腰椎骨折开放手术(OSS)与微创脊柱手术(MISS)后多裂肌及相应神经根的完整性。
我们调查了本机构接受MISS的前6例患者,并将其与6例年龄和性别匹配的曾接受OSS的随机患者进行对照。所有患者腰椎骨折形态相似,无脊髓损伤证据。所有患者均在术后至少6个月时接受超声肌肉量化和肌电图检查。在手术区域内及相邻部位的连续层面测量平均横截面积(CSA)。对每位患者在置入器械节段及相邻未置入器械节段进行同心针肌电图检查。
MISS组所有腰椎多裂肌的平均CSA为4.29cm²,OSS组为2.26cm²(p = 0.08)。在置入器械节段,MISS组的平均CSA为4.21cm²,OSS组为2.03cm²(p = 0.12)。在未置入器械的相邻节段,MISS组的平均CSA为4.46cm²,OSS组为2.87cm²(p = 0.05)。在未置入器械的相邻节段,MISS组6个节段中有5个节段的肌电图显示神经功能正常,而OSS组6个节段中只有1个节段(p = 0.03)。在置入器械节段,MISS组12个节段中有5个节段的神经功能正常,OSS组12个节段中有4个节段,OSS组有5个节段存在中度至重度去神经支配(p = 0.15)。
后路置入器械的MISS在保留脊神经后支内侧支方面明显优于OSS,且肌肉萎缩较少,尤其是在相邻节段。