Division of Cardiology and Department of Medicine, St. Lukes Roosevelt Hospital, 1111 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY, 10025, USA,
J Nucl Cardiol. 2013 Oct;20(5):719-30. doi: 10.1007/s12350-013-9763-6.
Due to the growth of cardiac testing and increasing cost of cardiovascular healthcare, the development of more cost-effective strategies has now become a dominant issue regarding future utilization of cardiac imaging procedures. To that end, we review the potential of combining two relatively inexpensive tests, the coronary artery calcium (CAC) scan and exercise electrocardiography (ECG), as a first-line test for the workup of patients with suspected coronary artery disease (CAD). The CAC scan was initially introduced as a screening test for CAD, based on data indicating that it is a specific marker for atherosclerosis, predicts clinical risk in accordance with the magnitude of CAC, and provides incremental information for prognostic risk compared to more readily available clinical data. However, CAC scores also predict the likelihood of observing myocardial ischemia among patients undergoing exercise myocardial perfusion SPECT imaging. Exercise ECG predicts clinical events according to the ST-segment response and according to functional exercise capacity, with the latter parameter as a stronger predictor of clinical outcomes. Like CAC scores, exercise functional capacity can also be used to predict the likelihood of ischemia since ischemia diminishes proportionally with increasing exercise capacity. Recent work indicates that when patients are designated by Bayesian analyses into low, intermediate, and high likelihood categories for CAD based on clinical data and the response to exercise ECG, the frequency of inducible myocardial ischemia is very low among both low and intermediate CAD likelihood patients who have a CAC score <400. Future studies are needed to investigate what clinical factors might further modify the CAC-ischemia relationship. On the basis of current data, an initial testing strategy that employs the combined calcium treadmill test has the inherent ability to designate a substantial number of intermediate likelihood patients who would not require further testing due to relatively low CAC scores and reasonable functional capacity.
由于心脏检查的增长和心血管保健成本的增加,开发更具成本效益的策略现在已成为未来心脏成像程序利用的主要问题。为此,我们回顾了将两种相对廉价的测试(冠状动脉钙(CAC)扫描和运动心电图(ECG))结合起来作为疑似冠心病(CAD)患者检查的一线测试的潜力。CAC 扫描最初是作为 CAD 的筛查测试引入的,基于以下数据:它是动脉粥样硬化的特定标志物,根据 CAC 的程度预测临床风险,与更易于获得的临床数据相比,为预后风险提供了额外的信息。然而,CAC 评分也可以预测在接受运动心肌灌注 SPECT 成像的患者中观察到心肌缺血的可能性。运动心电图根据 ST 段反应和功能运动能力预测临床事件,后者是临床结果的更强预测因子。与 CAC 评分一样,运动功能能力也可用于预测缺血的可能性,因为随着运动能力的增加,缺血的可能性会相应减少。最近的研究表明,当根据临床数据和运动 ECG 的反应通过贝叶斯分析将患者分为 CAD 的低、中和高可能性类别时,CAC 评分<400 的低和中度 CAD 可能性患者中诱导性心肌缺血的频率非常低。需要进一步的研究来调查哪些临床因素可能进一步改变 CAC 与缺血的关系。基于目前的数据,采用联合钙踏车测试的初始测试策略具有内在能力,可以指定大量的中间可能性患者,由于相对较低的 CAC 评分和合理的功能能力,他们不需要进一步的测试。