Huang Yu-Hua, Lin Jui-Wei
Department of Neurosurgery, Kaohsiung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital and Chang Gung University College of Medicine, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2013 Oct;115(10):2130-5. doi: 10.1016/j.clineuro.2013.08.007. Epub 2013 Aug 13.
Surgical treatment of spinal ependymomas requires careful consideration of the relative risks of neurological worsening from surgery. Our aim was to determine the risk factors of neurological deterioration after surgery for spinal ependymomas.
This 20-year study included 17 patients (seven men and 10 women; 44.65±13.62 years) with histologically confirmed spinal ependymomas. The basic features were reviewed and the functional status was assessed by using the modified McCormick classification. We subdivided the patient population into two groups according to whether neurological deterioration occurred after primary tumor resection (N=5) or not (N=12), and compared their clinical characteristics.
The average duration of presenting symptoms in the 17 patients was 23.53±21.45 months. Three (17.6%) patients underwent subtotal or partial resection and 14 (82.4%) patients underwent gross total resection. The incidence of neurological deterioration after primary resection of spinal ependymomas was 29.4%. There were five (100%) and two (16.7%) male patients in the neurological-deterioration and no-deterioration groups, respectively (p=0.003). The duration of presenting symptoms was 24 months or over in all the patients with neurological deterioration and five of the 12 patients with improved or stabilized function (p=0.044).
The risk associated with surgical resection of spinal ependymomas should not be overlooked because of the significant incidence of neurological deterioration. The male gender and long-standing symptom (≥24 months) are risk factors of postoperative neurological worsening. Early diagnosis and surgery are therefore critical for successful treatment of spinal ependymomas.
脊髓室管膜瘤的手术治疗需要仔细权衡手术导致神经功能恶化的相关风险。我们的目的是确定脊髓室管膜瘤手术后神经功能恶化的危险因素。
这项为期20年的研究纳入了17例经组织学确诊为脊髓室管膜瘤的患者(7例男性,10例女性;年龄44.65±13.62岁)。回顾了基本特征,并采用改良的麦考密克分类法评估功能状态。根据原发性肿瘤切除术后是否发生神经功能恶化,将患者人群分为两组(神经功能恶化组N = 5,未恶化组N = 12),并比较了两组的临床特征。
17例患者的平均症状持续时间为23.53±21.45个月。3例(17.6%)患者接受了次全或部分切除,14例(82.4%)患者接受了全切除。脊髓室管膜瘤初次切除术后神经功能恶化的发生率为29.4%。神经功能恶化组和未恶化组的男性患者分别有5例(100%)和2例(16.7%)(p = 0.003)。所有神经功能恶化的患者症状持续时间均为24个月及以上,12例功能改善或稳定的患者中有5例也是如此(p = 0.044)。
由于神经功能恶化的发生率较高,脊髓室管膜瘤手术切除相关的风险不容忽视。男性和长期症状(≥24个月)是术后神经功能恶化的危险因素。因此,早期诊断和手术对于脊髓室管膜瘤的成功治疗至关重要。