Montague Enid, Asan Onur
Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, University of Wisconsin - Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
Health Syst (Basingstoke). 2012 Dec 1;1(2):96-103. doi: 10.1057/hs.2012.11.
It is essential to design technologies and systems that promote appropriate interactions between physicians and patients. This study explored how physicians interact with Electronic Health Records (EHRs) to understand the qualities of the interaction between the physician and the EHR that may contribute to positive physician-patient interactions.
Video-taped observations of 100 medical consultations were used to evaluate interaction patterns between physicians and EHRs. Quantified observational methods were used to contribute to ecological validity.
Ten primary care physicians and 100 patients from five clinics participated in the study. Clinical encounters were recorded with video cameras and coded using a validated objective coding methodology in order to examine how physicians interact with electronic health records.
Three distinct styles were identified that characterize physician interactions with the EHR: technology-centered, human-centered, and mixed. Physicians who used a technology-centered style spent more time typing and gazing at the computer during the visit. Physicians who used a mixed style shifted their attention and body language between their patients and the technology throughout the visit. Physicians who used the human-centered style spent the least amount of time typing and focused more on the patient.
A variety of EHR interaction styles may be effective in facilitating patient-centered care. However, potential drawbacks of each style exist and are discussed. Future research on this topic and design strategies for effective health information technology in primary care are also discussed.
设计促进医生与患者之间适当互动的技术和系统至关重要。本研究探讨了医生如何与电子健康记录(EHR)互动,以了解医生与EHR之间互动的特质,这些特质可能有助于积极的医患互动。
对100次医疗会诊进行录像观察,以评估医生与EHR之间的互动模式。采用量化观察方法以提高生态效度。
来自五个诊所的10名初级保健医生和100名患者参与了该研究。临床会诊用摄像机记录,并使用经过验证的客观编码方法进行编码,以便检查医生如何与电子健康记录互动。
确定了三种不同的风格,这些风格表征了医生与EHR的互动:以技术为中心、以患者为中心和混合风格。采用以技术为中心风格的医生在就诊期间花更多时间打字和盯着电脑。采用混合风格的医生在整个就诊过程中在患者和技术之间转移注意力和肢体语言。采用以患者为中心风格的医生打字时间最少,更关注患者。
多种EHR互动风格可能在促进以患者为中心的护理方面有效。然而,每种风格都存在潜在缺点并进行了讨论。还讨论了关于该主题的未来研究以及初级保健中有效健康信息技术的设计策略。