Fittler Andras, Bősze Gergely, Botz Lajos
Department of Pharmaceutics, Medical School, University of Pecs, Pecs, Hungary.
J Med Internet Res. 2013 Sep 10;15(9):e199. doi: 10.2196/jmir.2606.
A growing number of online pharmacies have been established worldwide. Among them are numerous illegal websites selling medicine without valid medical prescriptions or distributing substandard or counterfeit drugs. Only a limited number of studies have been published on Internet pharmacies with regard to patient safety, professionalism, long-term follow-up, and pharmaceutical legitimacy verification.
In this study, we selected, evaluated, and followed 136 Internet pharmacy websites aiming to identify indicators of professional online pharmacy service and online medication safety.
An Internet search was performed by simulating the needs of potential customers of online pharmacies. A total of 136 Internet pharmacy websites were assessed and followed for four years. According to the LegitScript database, relevant characteristics such as longevity, time of continuous operation, geographical location, displayed contact information, prescription requirement, medical information exchange, and pharmaceutical legitimacy verification were recorded and evaluated.
The number of active Internet pharmacy websites decreased; 23 of 136 (16.9%) online pharmacies ceased operating within 12 months and only 67 monitored websites (49.3%) were accessible at the end of the four-year observation period. However, not all operated continuously, as about one-fifth (31/136) of all observed online pharmacy websites were inaccessible provisionally. Thus, only 56 (41.2%) Internet-based pharmacies were continuously operational. Thirty-one of the 136 online pharmacies (22.8%) had not provided any contact details, while only 59 (43.4%) displayed all necessary contact information on the website. We found that the declared physical location claims did not correspond to the area of domain registration (according to IP address) for most websites. Although the majority (120/136, 88.2%) of the examined Internet pharmacies distributed various prescription-only medicines, only 9 (6.6%) requested prior medical prescriptions before purchase. Medical information exchange was generally ineffective as 52 sites (38.2%) did not require any medical information from patients. The product information about the medicines was generally (126/136, 92.6%) not displayed adequately, and the contents of the patient information leaflet were incomplete in most cases (104/136, 76.5%). Numerous online operators (60/136, 44.1%) were defined as rogue Internet pharmacies, but no legitimate Internet-based pharmacies were among them. One site (0.7%) was yet unverified, 23 (16.9%) were unapproved, while the remaining (52/136, 38.2%) websites were not available in the LegitScript database. Contrary to our prior assumptions, prescription or medical information requirement, or the indication of contact information on the website, does not seem to correlate with "rogue pharmacy" status using the LegitScript online pharmacy verification standards. Instead, long-term continuous operation strongly correlated (P<.001) with explicit illegal activity.
Most Internet pharmacies in our study sample were illegal sites within the definition of "rogue" Internet pharmacy. These websites violate professional, legal, and ethical standards and endanger patient safety. This work shows evidence that online pharmacies that act illegally appear to have greater longevity than others, presumably because there is no compelling reason for frequent change in order to survive. We also found that one in five websites revived (closed down and reopened again within four years) and no-prescription sites with limited medicine and patient information are flourishing.
全球范围内已建立了越来越多的在线药店。其中有许多非法网站在没有有效医疗处方的情况下售药,或销售不合格药品或假药。关于在线药店在患者安全、专业性、长期随访以及药品合法性验证方面的研究仅有少数发表。
在本研究中,我们挑选、评估并跟踪了136个在线药店网站,旨在确定专业在线药店服务和在线用药安全的指标。
通过模拟在线药店潜在客户的需求进行互联网搜索。共评估并跟踪了136个在线药店网站四年。根据LegitScript数据库,记录并评估了诸如存续时间、连续运营时间、地理位置、显示的联系信息、处方要求、医疗信息交流以及药品合法性验证等相关特征。
活跃的在线药店网站数量减少;136个在线药店中有23个(16.9%)在12个月内停止运营,在四年观察期结束时,仅有67个被监测网站(49.3%)可访问。然而,并非所有网站都持续运营,因为所有观察到的在线药店网站中约五分之一(31/136)暂时无法访问。因此,仅有56个(41.2%)基于互联网的药店持续运营。136个在线药店中有31个(22.8%)未提供任何联系细节,而只有59个(43.4%)在网站上显示了所有必要的联系信息。我们发现,对于大多数网站而言,宣称的实际地理位置与域名注册地区(根据IP地址)不符。尽管大多数(120/136,88.2%)被检查的在线药店销售各种处方药,但只有9个(6.6%)在购买前要求提供先前的医疗处方。医疗信息交流通常无效,因为52个网站(38.2%)不要求患者提供任何医疗信息。关于药品的产品信息通常(126/136,92.6%)显示不充分,并且在大多数情况下(104/136,76.5%)患者信息单的内容不完整。众多在线运营者(60/136,44.1%)被定义为流氓互联网药店,但其中没有合法的基于互联网的药店。1个网站(0.7%)尚未验证,23个(16.9%)未获批准,而其余(52/136,38.2%)网站在LegitScript数据库中不可用。与我们先前的假设相反,使用LegitScript在线药店验证标准,处方或医疗信息要求或网站上联系信息的显示似乎与“流氓药店”状态无关。相反,长期持续运营与明确的非法活动密切相关(P<0.001)。
我们研究样本中的大多数互联网药店是“流氓”互联网药店定义范围内的非法网站。这些网站违反专业、法律和道德标准,危及患者安全。这项工作表明,非法经营的在线药店似乎比其他药店存续时间更长,大概是因为没有为了生存而频繁改变的迫切理由。我们还发现,五分之一的网站复苏(在四年内关闭并重新开业),且药品和患者信息有限的无处方网站正蓬勃发展。