Centre for Anatomical and Human Sciences, Hull York Medical School, University of Hull, Hull, UK.
J Anat. 2013 Oct;223(4):337-52. doi: 10.1111/joa.12085. Epub 2013 Aug 29.
All species demonstrate intraspecific anatomical variation. While generalisations such as Bergman's and Allen's rules have attempted to explain the geographic structuring of variation with some success, recent work has demonstrated limited support for these in certain Old World monkeys. This study extends this research to the baboon: a species that is widely distributed across sub-Saharan Africa and exhibits clinal variation across an environmentally disparate range. This study uses trend surface analysis to map the pattern of skull variation in size and shape in order to visualise the main axes of morphological variation. Patterns of shape and size-controlled shape are compared to highlight morphological variation that is underpinned by allometry alone. Partial regression is used to dissociate the effects of environmental terms, such as rainfall, temperature and spatial position. The diminutive Kinda baboon is outlying in size, so analyses were carried out with and without this taxon. Skull size variation demonstrates an east-west pattern, with small animals at the two extremes and large animals in Central and Southern Africa. Shape variation demonstrates the same geographical pattern as skull size, with small-sized animals exhibiting classic paedomorphic morphology. However, an additional north-south axis of variation emerges. After controlling for skull size, the diminutive Kinda baboon is no longer an outlier for size and shape. Also, the east-west component is no longer evident and discriminant function analysis shows an increased misclassification of adjacent taxa previously differentiated by size. This demonstrates the east-west component of shape variation is underpinned by skull size, while the north-south axis is not. The latter axis is explicable in phylogenetic terms: baboons arose in Southern Africa and colonised East and West Africa to the north, diverging in the process, aided by climate-mediated isolating mechanisms. Environmental terms appear poorly correlated with shape variation compared with geography. This might indicate that there is no simple environment-morphology association, but certainly demonstrates that phylogenetic history is an overbearing factor in baboon morphological variation.
所有物种都表现出种内解剖变异。虽然伯格曼和艾伦等规则的概括试图成功地解释变异的地理结构,但最近的研究表明,这些规则在某些旧世界猴子中支持有限。本研究将这一研究扩展到狒狒:一种广泛分布于撒哈拉以南非洲的物种,在环境差异很大的范围内表现出渐变变异。本研究使用趋势面分析来绘制大小和形状的颅骨变异模式,以便直观地显示形态变异的主要轴。比较形状和大小控制形状的模式,突出由比例单独支撑的形态变异。偏回归用于分离环境条件(如降雨量、温度和空间位置)的影响。体型较小的金达狒狒在体型上是外围的,因此在分析中包括和不包括这个分类群。颅骨大小变异表现出东西向的模式,两端是小型动物,中部和南部非洲是大型动物。形状变异表现出与颅骨大小相同的地理模式,小型动物表现出典型的幼态形态。然而,出现了另外一个南北轴的变异。在控制颅骨大小后,体型较小的金达狒狒在体型和形状上不再是一个异常值。此外,东西向成分不再明显,判别函数分析显示,以前按大小区分的相邻分类群的错误分类增加。这表明,形状变异的东西向成分是由颅骨大小支撑的,而南北轴则不是。后一轴在系统发育上是可以解释的:狒狒起源于南非,并向北迁徙到东非和西非,在这个过程中,气候介导的隔离机制促进了它们的分化。与地理相比,环境条件与形状变异的相关性较差。这可能表明不存在简单的环境-形态关联,但肯定表明,进化史是狒狒形态变异的一个主要因素。