Department of Veterinary Integrative Biosciences, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, United States.
Prev Vet Med. 2013 Nov 1;112(3-4):330-7. doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2013.08.009. Epub 2013 Aug 27.
This study compares the perceptions of producers and veterinarians on the economic impacts of Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis (MAP) infection in cow-calf herds. Questionnaires were mailed to beef producers through the Designated Johne's Coordinators and to veterinarians belonging to a nationwide professional organization. Important components of losses associated with MAP infected cows were used to estimate total loss per infected cow-year using an iterative approach based on collected survey data. Veterinarians were more likely to perceive a lower calving percentage in MAP infected cows compared to producers (P=0.02). Income lost due to the presence of Johne's disease (JD) in an infected cattle herd was perceived to be higher by veterinarians (P<0.01). Compared to veterinarians without JD certification, seedstock producers were more likely to perceive genetic losses due to culling cows positive for MAP (P<0.01). There were mixed opinions regarding the magnitude of lowered weaning weight in calves from infected cows and perceived differences in risk of other diseases or conditions in infected cows. An annual loss of $235 (95% CR: $89-$457) for each infected animal was estimated based on information from the producer survey. The analogous estimate using information inputs from veterinarians was $250 ($82-$486). Mean annual loss due to JD in a 100 cow herd with a 7% true prevalence was $1644 ($625-$3250) based on information provided by producers. Similarly, mean annual loss based on information collected from veterinarians was $1747 ($575-$3375).
本研究比较了生产者和兽医对牛犊牛群中分枝杆菌副结核亚种(MAP)感染的经济影响的看法。通过指定的约翰氏协调员向肉牛生产者邮寄了问卷,并向全国性专业组织的兽医邮寄了问卷。使用基于收集的调查数据的迭代方法,使用与 MAP 感染奶牛相关的损失的重要组成部分来估计每头受感染牛年的总损失。与生产者相比,兽医更有可能认为 MAP 感染奶牛的产犊率较低(P=0.02)。兽医认为,由于感染牛群中存在约翰氏病(JD)而导致的收入损失更高(P<0.01)。与没有 JD 认证的兽医相比,种畜生产者更有可能认为由于淘汰 MAP 阳性奶牛而导致的遗传损失(P<0.01)。对于来自感染奶牛的小牛断奶体重降低的幅度以及感染奶牛中其他疾病或状况的风险差异,存在不同的看法。根据生产者调查的信息,估计每头受感染动物每年损失 235 美元(95%置信区间:89-457 美元)。使用兽医提供的信息输入进行类似的估计,每年损失 250 美元(82-486 美元)。基于生产者提供的信息,在一个有 7%真实流行率的 100 头奶牛群中,JD 的年平均损失为 1644 美元(625-3250 美元)。同样,根据从兽医收集的信息,年平均损失为 1747 美元(575-3375 美元)。