Suno Manabu, Yoshida Toshiko, Koyama Toshihiro, Zamami Yoshito, Miyoshi Tomoko, Mizushima Takaaki, Tanimoto Mitsune
Medical Education Center, Okayama University.
Yakugaku Zasshi. 2013;133(10):1127-34. doi: 10.1248/yakushi.12-00254.
The concept of Team-Based Learning (TBL) was developed in the late 1970s by Larry Michaelsen, who wanted students to enjoy the benefits of small group learning within large classes in the business school environment. In contrast to problem-based learning (PBL), which is student centered, TBL is typically instructor centered. Recently, TBL is being used as a teaching method in over 60 health science professional schools in the US and other countries. In the present study, the impact of adopting TBL in teaching pharmaceutical care practices to students was evaluated. Students were required to answer a set of multiple-choice questions individually in individual readiness assessment test (IRAT) before the TBL sessions to assess their level of preparation. The same set of questions was then reattempted by the group readiness assessment test (GRAT) during TBL. Comparing the scores obtained in the GRAT and IRAT before the first TBL session, the scores from the GRAT were always higher than those of the IRAT, indicating that TBL has encouraged active learning. In addition, students were surveyed about their level of satisfaction with TBL and written comments about TBL were solicited. The results of the questionnaire showed that 87.3±9.3% of the students were satisfied. Moreover, no student commented that TBL was in any way inferior to the PBL. Implementation of a TBL approach was successfully integrated into the pharmaceutical care education course. In order to further improve the usefulness of TBL in teaching pharmaceutical care, a hybrid teaching approach that also comprises PBL and a lecture-based course is desirable.
团队协作学习(TBL)的概念是由拉里·迈克尔森在20世纪70年代末提出的,他希望学生能在商学院的大班环境中享受到小组学习的益处。与以学生为中心的基于问题的学习(PBL)不同,TBL通常以教师为中心。最近,TBL在美国和其他国家的60多所健康科学专业院校中被用作一种教学方法。在本研究中,评估了采用TBL向学生教授药学服务实践的影响。在TBL课程之前,学生需要在个人准备评估测试(IRAT)中单独回答一组多项选择题,以评估他们的准备水平。然后,在TBL期间,通过小组准备评估测试(GRAT)再次尝试相同的一组问题。比较第一次TBL课程之前在GRAT和IRAT中获得的分数,GRAT的分数总是高于IRAT的分数,这表明TBL促进了主动学习。此外,还对学生对TBL的满意度进行了调查,并征求了他们对TBL的书面意见。问卷调查结果显示,87.3±9.3%的学生表示满意。此外,没有学生评论说TBL在任何方面不如PBL。TBL方法的实施已成功融入药学服务教育课程。为了进一步提高TBL在药学服务教学中的实用性,一种还包括PBL和基于讲座的课程的混合教学方法是可取的。