Yu Xiaonan, Liu Bin, Pei Yuru, Xu Tianmin
a PhD Student, Department of Orthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, Haidian District, Beijing, China.
Angle Orthod. 2014 May;84(3):410-6. doi: 10.2319/071513-516.1. Epub 2013 Oct 3.
To establish an objective method for evaluating facial attractiveness from a set of orthodontic photographs.
One hundred eight malocclusion patients randomly selected from six universities in China were randomly divided into nine groups, with each group containing an equal number of patients with Class I, II, and III malocclusions. Sixty-nine expert Chinese orthodontists ranked photographs of the patients (frontal, lateral, and frontal smiling photos) before and after orthodontic treatment from "most attractive" to "least attractive" in each group. A weighted mean ranking was then calculated for each patient, based on which a three-point scale was created. Procrustes superimposition was conducted on 101 landmarks identified on the photographs. A support vector regression (SVR) function was set up according to the coordinate values of identified landmarks of each photographic set and its corresponding grading. Its predictive ability was tested for each group in turn.
The average coincidence rate obtained for comparisons of the subjective ratings with the SVR evaluation was 71.8% according to 18 verification tests.
Geometric morphometrics combined with SVR may be a prospective method for objective comprehensive evaluation of facial attractiveness in the near future.
从一组正畸照片中建立一种评估面部吸引力的客观方法。
从中国六所大学随机选取108例错牙合患者,随机分为9组,每组中I类、II类和III类错牙合患者数量相等。69名中国正畸专家对患者正畸治疗前后的照片(正面、侧面和正面微笑照片)在每组中从“最有吸引力”到“最无吸引力”进行排序。然后计算每位患者的加权平均排名,并据此创建一个三点量表。对照片上识别出的101个地标点进行普氏叠加。根据每组照片识别出的地标点坐标值及其相应等级建立支持向量回归(SVR)函数。依次对每组进行预测能力测试。
根据18次验证测试,主观评分与SVR评估比较的平均符合率为71.8%。
几何形态测量学结合SVR可能是在不久的将来对面部吸引力进行客观综合评估的一种前瞻性方法。