Almesbah Fajer, Mandiwanza Tafadzwa, Kaliaperumal Chandrasekaran, Caird John, Crimmins Darach
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland; and.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2013 Dec;12(6):615-21. doi: 10.3171/2013.8.PEDS13254. Epub 2013 Oct 4.
The frequency with which routine preoperative blood test results predict perioperative or postoperative complications is insignificant. The unnecessary ordering of routine tests increases the financial costs and patients' distress. The authors evaluated the effects of routine preoperative testing on patient management and the overall financial costs.
The authors retrospectively reviewed the medical records and laboratory data for 355 children admitted to the neurosurgical department for elective procedures over a 5-year period (January 2008-December 2012). They excluded all patients admitted for imaging or surgical procedures requiring local anesthesia, and they recorded the results of preoperative and previous (up to 6 months before surgery) blood tests and any abnormalities noted.
As a result of the 3489 blood tests ordered preoperatively for 328 (94.6%) of the 355 patients, 29 abnormalities (9%) were detected. Most of these abnormal values were near the reference range, and none significantly affected the progression of scheduled procedures. For only 1 patient (0.28%) was the procedure cancelled because of an abnormality (preoperative partial thromboplastin time), which further testing showed to be a false-positive result. The cost of these tests over 5 years was 5205-10,410 euros ($6766-$13,533 US).
Preoperative tests should be selectively requested on the basis of clinical indication.
术前常规血液检查结果预测围手术期或术后并发症的频率微不足道。常规检查的不必要开具增加了经济成本和患者的痛苦。作者评估了术前常规检查对患者管理和总体经济成本的影响。
作者回顾性分析了5年期间(2008年1月至2012年12月)因择期手术入住神经外科的355名儿童的病历和实验室数据。他们排除了所有因需要局部麻醉的影像学或外科手术而入院的患者,并记录了术前和之前(手术前6个月内)的血液检查结果以及任何异常情况。
对355名患者中的328名(94.6%)进行了术前3489次血液检查,检测到29项异常(9%)。这些异常值大多接近参考范围,没有一项对预定手术的进展产生显著影响。只有1名患者(0.28%)因异常(术前部分凝血活酶时间)取消了手术,进一步检查显示这是一个假阳性结果。这些检查在5年期间的费用为5205 - 10410欧元(6766 - 13533美元)。
应根据临床指征选择性地进行术前检查。