Department of Neurology, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA.
MGH Epilepsy Service, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2014 Feb;125(2):263-9. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2013.07.028. Epub 2013 Oct 1.
Previous studies based solely on visual EEG analysis reported equivocal results regarding an association of pharmaco-resistance with EEG asymmetries in genetic generalized epilepsies (GGE). We addressed this issue by applying both visual and quantitative methods to the pretreatment EEG of GGE patients.
Socio-demographic/disease characteristics and response to treatment/discontinuation trial for these patients were recorded at 6months and at last follow up. The first EEG was retrospectively, blindly, and visually assessed for focal slowing, focal discharges and also quantitatively analyzed for amplitude or latency asymmetries of generalized discharges. Association between these variables and development of drug-resistance was evaluated.
Out of 51 subjects, 40% had some type of EEG asymmetry by visual, 37% by quantitative and 54% by combined analysis. Drug-resistance was identified in 52% of patients after 6months and in 24% at the end of the follow up period (∼4.2years). 27% of patients underwent a discontinuation trial; 43% unsuccessfully. There was no association between baseline EEG asymmetries of any type and refractoriness to medical therapy, regardless of analytical method used.
In a carefully selected cohort of medication-naïve GGE patients, visual and quantitative asymmetries in the first EEG were not associated with the development of pharmaco-resistance.
These findings do not provide support for utilization of EEG asymmetries as a prognostic tool in GGE.
先前仅基于视觉脑电图分析的研究报告称,遗传全面性癫痫(GGE)中药物抵抗与脑电图不对称之间存在关联的结果存在争议。我们通过对 GGE 患者的治疗前脑电图应用视觉和定量方法来解决这个问题。
在 6 个月和最后一次随访时记录这些患者的社会人口统计学/疾病特征和对治疗/停药试验的反应。对第一次脑电图进行回顾性、盲法和视觉评估,以评估局灶性减速、局灶性放电,以及对全面性放电的幅度或潜伏期不对称进行定量分析。评估这些变量与耐药性发展之间的关联。
在 51 名受试者中,40%通过视觉、37%通过定量和 54%通过联合分析存在某种类型的脑电图不对称。在 6 个月后和随访结束时(约 4.2 年),52%的患者出现药物抵抗,24%的患者出现药物抵抗。27%的患者进行了停药试验;43%不成功。无论使用何种分析方法,基线脑电图的任何类型的不对称都与对药物治疗的抵抗性无关。
在精心挑选的药物初治 GGE 患者队列中,第一次脑电图的视觉和定量不对称与药物抵抗的发展无关。
这些发现不支持将脑电图不对称作为 GGE 的预后工具。