Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences, Stephanstr. 1a, 04109 Leipzig, Germany.
Department of Psychology, Royal Holloway University of London, Egham, Surrey TW20 0EX, United Kingdom.
Neuropsychologia. 2014 Jan;52:82-92. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2013.09.034. Epub 2013 Oct 1.
People generally have a strong and immediate intuition whether they are the author of an action or not. Nevertheless, recent psychological studies focused on situations of ambiguous agency. These studies concluded that agency is an inference rather than a direct perception, and is, at least sometimes, illusory. Moreover, shared representations of executed and merely observed actions within the sensorimotor system pose a challenge to the idea that a sense of agency can be grounded within that system. Here, we sought to investigate whether the human motor system is indeed sensitive to whether observed actions are linked to agency or not. In addition, we investigated whether the mere observation of an action has comparable effects on low-level, sensorimotor measures of agency, and on high-level, explicit representations of agency. To this end, we instructed participants to make simple manual movements, and manipulated the temporal correspondence between the movement that they made and the movement that they observed. Motor-evoked potentials to single-pulse TMS were taken as a low-level, sensorimotor measure of agency. To assess explicit representations of agency, participants verbally judged whether or not the observed movement temporally corresponded to the movement they executed. The results showed that corticospinal excitability varied with the degree of temporal correspondence of the executed and observed movements. Moreover, explicit agency judgments could be predicted from corticospinal excitability. This suggests that explicit judgments of agency could be directly based on information within the sensorimotor system.
人们通常对自己是否是某个行为的作者有着强烈而直接的直觉。然而,最近的心理学研究集中在模糊的代理情境上。这些研究得出结论,代理是一种推断,而不是直接感知,而且至少在某些时候是虚幻的。此外,执行动作和仅仅观察到的动作在感觉运动系统中的共同表示对代理感可以基于该系统的观点提出了挑战。在这里,我们试图研究人类运动系统是否确实对观察到的动作是否与代理相关敏感。此外,我们还研究了仅仅观察动作是否对代理的低水平、感觉运动测量以及对代理的高水平、明确表示产生类似的影响。为此,我们指示参与者进行简单的手动运动,并操纵他们进行的运动与他们观察到的运动之间的时间对应关系。单脉冲 TMS 诱发的运动诱发电位被用作代理的低水平、感觉运动测量。为了评估代理的明确表示,参与者口头判断观察到的运动是否与他们执行的运动在时间上对应。结果表明,皮质脊髓兴奋性随执行和观察运动的时间对应程度而变化。此外,皮质脊髓兴奋性可以预测明确的代理判断。这表明代理的明确判断可以直接基于感觉运动系统内的信息。