Brouwer R M, Follath F, Bühler F R
J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1985;7 Suppl 4:S38-44. doi: 10.1097/00005344-198507004-00008.
The complementary antihypertensive effects of the beta-blocker/calcium antagonist combination has to be weighed against their additive and potentially detrimental negative inotropic, chronotropic, and dromotropic effects inherent in both classes of drugs. We reviewed the main adversity, particularly electrophysiological and hemodynamic effects, of combined treatments with beta-blockers and the calcium antagonists verapamil, diltiazem, and nifedipine. In patients with coronary artery disease, a different picture emerged between the verapamil and nifedipine combination with a beta-blocker. Verapamil was more often associated with conduction problems (up to 9%) and dyspnea or heart failure (up to 8%). These problems had rarely been reported with nifedipine but ankle edema (up to 11%), flushing (up to 11%), and headaches (up to 7%) predominated. The cardiovascular unwanted effects led to withdrawal in 5-8% for the verapamil/beta-blocker or nifedipine/beta-blocker combination. Although there was little cardiac adversity with the nifedipine/beta-blocker combination, the intravenous administration of verapamil in patients on beta-blockers is contraindicated and the oral verapamil/beta-blocker combination should not be sought in patients with impaired left ventricular function and when conduction disturbances are likely to occur. In treating hypertensive patients without overt coronary artery disease, there is no argument against the use of the nifedipine/beta-blocker combination but there is a need for definitive studies of the verapamil/beta-blocker combination.
β受体阻滞剂与钙拮抗剂联合使用的降压协同作用,必须与其两类药物固有的相加且可能有害的负性肌力、负性频率及负性传导作用相权衡。我们回顾了β受体阻滞剂与钙拮抗剂维拉帕米、地尔硫䓬和硝苯地平联合治疗的主要不良反应,尤其是电生理和血流动力学效应。在冠心病患者中,维拉帕米与β受体阻滞剂联合使用和硝苯地平与β受体阻滞剂联合使用呈现出不同的情况。维拉帕米更常与传导问题(高达9%)以及呼吸困难或心力衰竭(高达8%)相关。硝苯地平很少出现这些问题,但踝部水肿(高达11%)、面部潮红(高达11%)和头痛(高达7%)较为常见。心血管方面的不良反应导致维拉帕米/β受体阻滞剂或硝苯地平/β受体阻滞剂联合治疗组中有5 - 8%的患者停药。虽然硝苯地平/β受体阻滞剂联合使用时心脏方面的不良反应较少,但β受体阻滞剂治疗的患者禁忌静脉注射维拉帕米,对于左心室功能受损以及可能发生传导障碍的患者,不应寻求口服维拉帕米/β受体阻滞剂联合治疗。在治疗无明显冠心病的高血压患者时,使用硝苯地平/β受体阻滞剂联合治疗并无争议,但对于维拉帕米/β受体阻滞剂联合治疗需要进行确定性研究。