Caltagirone C, Masullo C, Benedetti N, Nocentini U
Schweiz Arch Neurol Psychiatr (1985). 1985;136(3):7-23.
We carried out a neuropsychological study on cognitive impairment in 57 subjects affected by idiopathic Parkinson's Disease (P.D.) and 32 subjects affected by Alzheimer's Disease (A.D.). First, we found two different subgroups of parkinsonian patients, the first one with dementia and the second one without dementia. We clearly identified these two distinct subclinical entities regardless of mean age, age of onset, duration of treatment; on the contrary, the type of treatment seems to play a specific role on the appearance of dementia in P.D., anticholinergics being assumed almost exclusively by demented parkinsonian patients (chi square c. Yates = 422; p less than 0.05). Second, we showed two distinct patterns of cognitive impairment between P.D. with dementia and A.D. In fact, cognitive impairment is consistently more evident in Alzheimer patients than in parkinsonian ones with dementia; in addition, demented parkinsonians show a pattern of impairment similar to that exhibited by patients affected by frontal lobe lesions. This result supports neuroanatomical and neurochemical data on the involvement of the whole dopaminergic system in P.D. and the role played by the ventro-medial tegmental area projecting to the frontal cortex. In conclusion, our study, identifying a specific pattern of cognitive impairment in P.D., well-differenciated from demented patients of different aetiology, suggests beneficial effects with dopaminergic agonists in these patients; in fact, these agents, acting on the second neuron, may stimulate the prefrontal region that is probably involved in the cognitive impairment of parkinsonian patients.
我们对57名特发性帕金森病(P.D.)患者和32名阿尔茨海默病(A.D.)患者的认知障碍进行了神经心理学研究。首先,我们发现帕金森病患者存在两个不同的亚组,第一组患有痴呆,第二组未患痴呆。无论平均年龄、发病年龄、治疗持续时间如何,我们都能清晰地识别出这两个不同的亚临床实体;相反,治疗类型似乎在帕金森病痴呆的出现中起特定作用,抗胆碱能药物几乎仅被患有痴呆的帕金森病患者使用(卡方检验c. Yates = 422;p小于0.05)。其次,我们展示了帕金森病痴呆患者和阿尔茨海默病患者之间两种不同的认知障碍模式。事实上,认知障碍在阿尔茨海默病患者中始终比患有痴呆的帕金森病患者更明显;此外,患有痴呆的帕金森病患者表现出的障碍模式与额叶病变患者相似。这一结果支持了关于整个多巴胺能系统参与帕金森病以及投射到额叶皮质的腹内侧被盖区所起作用的神经解剖学和神经化学数据。总之,我们的研究识别出了帕金森病中一种特定的认知障碍模式,与不同病因的痴呆患者有明显区别,提示多巴胺能激动剂对这些患者可能有益;事实上,这些药物作用于第二神经元,可能刺激可能与帕金森病患者认知障碍有关的前额叶区域。