Department of Neurology, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Department of Neurology, Boston Medical Center, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
Seizure. 2014 Jan;23(1):47-54. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2013.09.011. Epub 2013 Sep 25.
Little is known about the effect of psychogenic non epileptic seizures (PNES) to caregiver quality of life (QOL), particularly as it compares to epileptic seizures (ES). We sought to characterize this effect and identify its determinants.
The study population comprised of 126 ES and 33 PNES patients who underwent video EEG monitoring along with 48 and 18 caregivers respectively who accompanied them to their investigations. Patients completed questionnaires providing demographic, disease-related, cognitive, psychiatric, sleep and QOL information on admission, prior to their diagnosis being clarified. Their caregivers completed questionnaires providing demographic, disease burden and generic QOL information. Paraclinical data were also gathered. Regression analysis was used to identify patient and caregiver related determinants of patient and caregiver QOL.
QOL scores were significantly worse for PNES than ES patients and were mainly linked to depression levels. PNES and ES caregivers had comparable demographic characteristics and QOL scores. ES caregiver QOL was better in employed caregivers with lower burden scores for the physical component summary (PCS) and worse in female caregivers of depressed patients with higher burden scores for the mental component summary (MCS). Caregiver burden score was the strongest correlate of PNES caregiver MCS QOL score.
Caregiver QOL in PNES does not differ from caregiver QOL in ES, while patient QOL is worse in PNES. Caregiver burden emerges as a consistent correlate of caregiver QOL both in ES and PNES. These findings advocate for consideration of caregiver burden and QOL in PNES in clinical practice and for future research paradigms.
关于心因性非癫痫性发作(PNES)对照顾者生活质量(QOL)的影响知之甚少,尤其是与癫痫发作(ES)相比。我们旨在描述这种影响,并确定其决定因素。
研究人群包括 126 例 ES 和 33 例 PNES 患者,他们分别接受了视频脑电图监测以及 48 名和 18 名照顾者的陪同。患者在入院时、在明确诊断之前完成了问卷调查,提供了人口统计学、疾病相关、认知、精神、睡眠和 QOL 信息。他们的照顾者完成了问卷调查,提供了人口统计学、疾病负担和一般 QOL 信息。还收集了临床数据。回归分析用于确定患者和照顾者相关因素对患者和照顾者 QOL 的影响。
PNES 患者的 QOL 评分明显低于 ES 患者,主要与抑郁水平有关。PNES 和 ES 照顾者具有相似的人口统计学特征和 QOL 评分。ES 照顾者的 QOL 在工作的照顾者中更好,他们的身体成分综合评分(PCS)负担较低,而在患有抑郁的女性患者的照顾者中更差,他们的心理成分综合评分(MCS)负担较高。照顾者负担评分是 PNES 照顾者 MCS QOL 评分的最强相关因素。
PNES 照顾者的 QOL 与 ES 照顾者的 QOL 没有差异,而 PNES 患者的 QOL 更差。照顾者负担是 ES 和 PNES 中照顾者 QOL 的一致相关因素。这些发现提倡在临床实践中考虑 PNES 中的照顾者负担和 QOL,并为未来的研究模式提供依据。