Yau Christina, Sninsky John, Kwok Shirley, Wang Alice, Degnim Amy, Ingle James N, Gillett Cheryl, Tutt Andrew, Waldman Fred, Moore Dan, Esserman Laura, Benz Christopher C
Breast Cancer Res. 2013;15(5):R103. doi: 10.1186/bcr3567.
Outcome predictors in use today are prognostic only for hormone receptor-positive (HRpos) breast cancer. Although microarray-derived multigene predictors of hormone receptor-negative (HRneg) and/or triple negative (Tneg) breast cancer recurrence risk are emerging, to date none have been transferred to clinically suitable assay platforms (for example, RT-PCR) or validated against formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) HRneg/Tneg samples.
Multiplexed RT-PCR was used to assay two microarray-derived HRneg/Tneg prognostic signatures IR-7 and Buck-4) in a pooled FFPE collection of 139 chemotherapy-naïve HRneg breast cancers. The prognostic value of the RTPCR measured gene signatures were evaluated as continuous and dichotomous variables, and in conditional risk models incorporating clinical parameters. An optimized five-gene index was derived by evaluating gene combinations from both signatures.
RT-PCR measured IR-7 and Buck-4 signatures proved prognostic as continuous variables; and conditional risk modeling chose nodal status, the IR-7 signature, and tumor grade as significant predictors of distant recurrence (DR). From the Buck-4 and IR-7 signatures, an optimized five-gene (TNFRSF17, CLIC5, HLA-F, CXCL13, XCL2) predictor was generated, referred to as the Integrated Cytokine Score (ICS) based on its functional pathway linkage through interferon-γ and IL-10. Across all FFPE cases, the ICS was prognostic as either a continuous or dichotomous variable, and conditional risk modeling selected nodal status and ICS as DR predictors. Further dichotomization of node-negative/ICS-low FFPE cases identified a subset of low-grade HRneg tumors with <10% 5-year DR risk. The prognostic value of ICS was reaffirmed in two previously studied microarray assayed cohorts containing 274 node-negative and chemotherapy naive HRneg breast cancers, including 95 Tneg cases where it proved prognostically independent of Tneg molecular subtyping. In additional HRneg/Tneg microarray assayed cohorts, the five-gene ICS also proved prognostic irrespective of primary tumor nodal status and adjuvant chemotherapy intervention.
We advanced the measurement of two previously reported microarray-derived HRneg/Tneg breast cancer prognostic signatures for use in FFPE samples, and derived an optimized five-gene Integrated Cytokine Score (ICS) with multi-platform capability of predicting metastatic outcome from primary HRneg/Tneg tumors independent of nodal status, adjuvant chemotherapy use, and Tneg molecular subtype.
目前使用的预后指标仅对激素受体阳性(HRpos)乳腺癌具有预后价值。尽管源自微阵列的激素受体阴性(HRneg)和/或三阴性(Tneg)乳腺癌复发风险的多基因预测指标正在兴起,但迄今为止,尚无任何指标被转移至临床适用的检测平台(例如逆转录聚合酶链反应(RT-PCR))或针对福尔马林固定石蜡包埋(FFPE)的HRneg/Tneg样本进行验证。
采用多重RT-PCR检测139例未经化疗的HRneg乳腺癌FFPE样本集合中的两种源自微阵列的HRneg/Tneg预后特征(IR-7和Buck-4)。将RT-PCR检测的基因特征的预后价值评估为连续变量和二分变量,并纳入临床参数的条件风险模型中进行评估。通过评估来自两种特征的基因组合得出优化的五基因指数。
RT-PCR检测的IR-7和Buck-4特征作为连续变量被证明具有预后价值;条件风险模型选择淋巴结状态、IR-7特征和肿瘤分级作为远处复发(DR)的重要预测指标。从Buck-4和IR-7特征中,生成了一个优化的五基因(肿瘤坏死因子受体超家族成员17(TNFRSF17)、氯离子细胞内通道蛋白5(CLIC5)、人类白细胞抗原F(HLA-F)、CXC趋化因子配体13(CXCL13)、C趋化因子配体2(XCL2))预测指标,基于其通过干扰素-γ和白细胞介素-10的功能途径联系,称为综合细胞因子评分(ICS)。在所有FFPE病例中,ICS作为连续变量或二分变量均具有预后价值,条件风险模型选择淋巴结状态和ICS作为DR预测指标。对淋巴结阴性/ICS低的FFPE病例进一步二分法分析,确定了一组5年DR风险<10%的低级别HRneg肿瘤亚组。ICS的预后价值在两个先前研究的微阵列检测队列中得到再次确认,这两个队列包含274例淋巴结阴性且未经化疗的HRneg乳腺癌,其中包括95例Tneg病例,在这些病例中,ICS被证明在预后上独立于Tneg分子亚型。在其他HRneg/Tneg微阵列检测队列中,五基因ICS也被证明具有预后价值,无论原发性肿瘤的淋巴结状态和辅助化疗干预情况如何。
我们推进了对两种先前报道的源自微阵列的HRneg/Tneg乳腺癌预后特征的检测,使其可用于FFPE样本,并得出了一个优化的五基因综合细胞因子评分(ICS),该评分具有多平台预测原发性HRneg/Tneg肿瘤转移结局的能力,独立于淋巴结状态、辅助化疗的使用和Tneg分子亚型。