Division of Psychology and Language Sciences, University College London, Chandler House, 2 Wakefield Street, London, WC1N 1PF, United Kingdom.
Department of Human Communication Sciences, University of Sheffield, 362 Mushroom Lane, Sheffield, S10 2TS, United Kingdom.
Neuropsychologia. 2014 Jan;53:25-38. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2013.10.014. Epub 2013 Oct 31.
One factor in syntactic impairment in aphasia might be damage to general structure processing systems. In such a case, deficits would be evident in the processing of syntactically structured non-linguistic information. To explore this hypothesis, we examined performances on artificial grammar learning (AGL) tasks in which the grammar was expressed in non-linguistic visual forms. In the first experiment, AGL behavior of four aphasic participants with severe syntactic impairment, five aphasic participants without syntactic impairment, and healthy controls was examined. Participants were trained on sequences of nonsense stimuli with the structure A(n)B(n). Data were analyzed at an individual level to identify different behavioral profiles and account for heterogeneity in aphasic as well as healthy groups. Healthy controls and patients without syntactic impairment were more likely to learn configurational (item order) than quantitative (counting) regularities. Quantitative regularities were only detected by individuals who also detected the configurational properties of the stimulus sequences. By contrast, two individuals with syntactic impairment learned quantitative regularities, but showed no sensitivity towards configurational structure. They also failed to detect configurational structure in a second experiment in which sequences were structured by the grammar A(+)B(+). We discuss the potential relationship between AGL and processing of word order as well as the potential of AGL in clinical practice.
在失语症中,句法损伤的一个因素可能是对一般结构处理系统的损伤。在这种情况下,句法结构的非语言信息处理会出现缺陷。为了探索这一假设,我们研究了人工语法学习(AGL)任务的表现,其中语法以非语言的视觉形式表达。在第一个实验中,我们检查了 4 名严重句法损伤的失语症患者、5 名无句法损伤的失语症患者和健康对照组的 AGL 行为。参与者接受了具有结构 A(n)B(n)的无意义刺激序列的训练。对数据进行了个体水平的分析,以确定不同的行为特征,并解释失语症和健康组的异质性。健康对照组和无句法损伤的患者更有可能学习配置(项目顺序)而不是定量(计数)规则。只有那些也检测到刺激序列配置属性的个体才能检测到定量规则。相比之下,两名有句法损伤的个体学习了定量规则,但对配置结构没有敏感性。他们也未能在第二个实验中检测到由语法 A(+)B(+)构建的序列的配置结构。我们讨论了 AGL 与词序处理之间的潜在关系,以及 AGL 在临床实践中的潜力。