Antoun Angelle, Wilson Benjamin
Department of Psychology, Emory University, 36 Eagle Row, Atlanta, GA, 30322, USA.
Emory National Primate Research Center, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2025 Feb;87(2):565-576. doi: 10.3758/s13414-024-02989-1. Epub 2024 Dec 26.
When we encounter an unfamiliar word in a sentence, word order can be used to determine the grammatical category to which that word belongs and clarify ambiguity. However, it is unclear whether a similar categorization effect occurs in nonlinguistic contexts. We created three perceptually distinct categories of shape stimuli-rounded (A); squared (B); pointed (C). Participants were first taught to categorize these shapes, then participants in the experimental condition were trained to select them in a fixed sequence order (A→ B → C) while participants in the control condition were allowed to select them in any order. We then generated ambiguous stimuli by morphing shapes from different categories together. In the experimental condition, when an ambiguous morph was presented in a sequence, its subsequent categorization radically shifted based on which shape it replaced. For example, when an AB morph replaced the A shape in a sequence, it was more likely to be categorized as A. By contrast, participants in the control condition, who selected these stimuli without a fixed sequence order, showed no effect, demonstrating the critical role of sequence order and ruling out alternative explanations. These results demonstrate that, even using nonlinguistic stimuli, the position in which an ambiguous stimulus occurs in a sequence drastically impacts how it is subsequently categorized.
当我们在一个句子中遇到不熟悉的单词时,可以利用词序来确定该单词所属的语法类别,并消除歧义。然而,尚不清楚在非语言情境中是否会出现类似的分类效应。我们创建了三类在感知上明显不同的形状刺激——圆形(A)、方形(B)、尖角形(C)。首先让参与者学会对这些形状进行分类,然后对处于实验条件下的参与者进行训练,使其按照固定的顺序(A→B→C)选择这些形状,而处于控制条件下的参与者则可以按任意顺序选择。接着,我们通过将不同类别的形状进行变形处理来生成模糊刺激。在实验条件下,当一个模糊变形形状按顺序呈现时,其后续的分类会根据它所替代的形状而发生根本性的转变。例如,当一个AB变形形状在序列中替代A形状时,它更有可能被分类为A。相比之下,处于控制条件下的参与者在选择这些刺激时没有固定的顺序,他们没有表现出这种效应,这证明了顺序的关键作用,并排除了其他解释。这些结果表明,即使使用非语言刺激,一个模糊刺激在序列中出现的位置也会极大地影响它随后的分类方式。