Anagnostou E, Constantinides V, Anagnostou E, Paraskevas G, Christidi F, Zalonis I, Stamboulis E, Kararizou E
Department of Neurology, Eginition Hospital, University of Athens, Athens, Greece.
Psychiatriki. 2013 Jul-Sep;24(3):197-201.
Mood and pain are interrelated to each other in a mutual and complex manner. Patient populations in headache clinics exhibit more emotional disturbance than general practice patients. Nonetheless, the degree of psychological illness among headache patients is less than maybe found in psychiatric outpatients. However, it is a fact that several psychiatric disorders appear to be comorbid with primary headache syndromes such as migraine. Still, prospective standardized studies are sparse. We aimed to investigate whether migraine per se or specific migraine characteristics are associated to depression and anxiety. In a single center study (Department of Neurology of the University of Athens) migraineurs were asked for several headache features such as pain intensity, attack frequency, average attack duration, prodromal symptoms and the presence of aura. We assessed 50 consecutive headache patients who were referred to our headache outpatient clinic. Patients diagnosed with non-migraine syndromes, mixed non-migraine and migraine syndromes, or patients with previously diagnosed systemic disease known to precipitate psychiatric disorders (such as systemic lupus erythematodes) were excluded from the study. Furthermore, we did not include any subjects who were already on antidepressive or other psychiatric medication. Twenty four patients met the inclusion criteria. The data were then correlated with scores obtained by the Beck Depression Inventory and the Hamilton's scales for Depression and Anxiety. Our results showed an increased frequency of mild and moderate depression compared to what was expected from the normal population which is in line with past observations on headache patients. In an analogous manner, mild and moderate anxiety appeared more frequently among migraineurs than healthy subjects. However, we did not find any significant relation between depression or anxiety and parameters such as pain intensity, monthly attack frequency, attack duration, presence or absence of aura, appearance of pre-ictal prodromal symptoms and migraine career duration (age of assessment minus age of migraine onset). These findings suggest that migraine, although often comorbid with depression and anxiety, has no specific headache characteristics causally related to mood abnormalities. Larger samples will be required in future studies to address the question of a link between more specific mood and mental disturbances with primary headache syndromes.
情绪与疼痛以一种相互且复杂的方式相互关联。头痛诊所的患者群体比普通门诊患者表现出更多的情绪障碍。尽管如此,头痛患者的心理疾病程度低于精神科门诊患者。然而,事实上几种精神疾病似乎与偏头痛等原发性头痛综合征共病。不过,前瞻性标准化研究较少。我们旨在调查偏头痛本身或特定的偏头痛特征是否与抑郁和焦虑有关。在一项单中心研究(雅典大学神经病学系)中,向偏头痛患者询问了几种头痛特征,如疼痛强度、发作频率、平均发作持续时间、前驱症状和先兆的存在情况。我们评估了连续转诊至我们头痛门诊的50例头痛患者。被诊断为非偏头痛综合征、非偏头痛和偏头痛混合综合征的患者,或先前诊断有已知会引发精神疾病的全身性疾病(如系统性红斑狼疮)的患者被排除在研究之外。此外,我们没有纳入任何已经在服用抗抑郁药或其他精神科药物的受试者。24例患者符合纳入标准。然后将数据与贝克抑郁量表以及汉密尔顿抑郁和焦虑量表获得的分数进行关联。我们的结果显示,与正常人群预期相比,轻度和中度抑郁的发生率增加,这与过去对头痛患者的观察结果一致。以类似的方式,轻度和中度焦虑在偏头痛患者中比健康受试者中更频繁出现。然而,我们没有发现抑郁或焦虑与疼痛强度、每月发作频率、发作持续时间、先兆的有无以及发作前前驱症状的出现和偏头痛病程(评估年龄减去偏头痛发病年龄)等参数之间存在任何显著关系。这些发现表明,偏头痛虽然常常与抑郁和焦虑共病,但没有与情绪异常有因果关系的特定头痛特征。未来的研究需要更大的样本量来解决更具体的情绪和精神障碍与原发性头痛综合征之间联系的问题。