Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, The Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago/Northwestern McGaw Medical Center, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Pain Med. 2014 Feb;15(2):292-305. doi: 10.1111/pme.12283. Epub 2013 Nov 13.
Review the current evidence-based pharmacotherapy for phantom limb pain (PLP) in the context of the current understanding of the pathophysiology of this condition.
We conducted a systematic review of original research papers specifically investigating the pharmacologic treatment of PLP. Literature was sourced from PubMed, Embase, Scopus, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL). Studies with animals, "neuropathic" but not "phantom limb" pain, or without pain scores and/or functional measures as primary outcomes were excluded. A level of evidence 1-4 was ascribed to individual treatments. These levels included meta-analysis or systematic reviews (level 1), one or more well-powered randomized, controlled trials (level 2), retrospective studies, open-label trials, pilot studies (level 3), and anecdotes, case reports, or clinical experience (level 4).
We found level 2 evidence for gabapentin, both oral (PO) and intravenous (IV) morphine, tramadol, intramuscular (IM) botulinum toxin, IV and epidural Ketamine, level 3 evidence for amitriptyline, dextromethorphan, topiramate, IV calcitonin, PO memantine, continuous perineural catheter analgesia with ropivacaine, and level 4 evidence for methadone, intrathecal (IT) buprenorphine, IT and epidural fentanyl, duloxetine, fluoxetine, mirtazapine, clonazepam, milnacipran, capsaicin, and pregabalin.
Currently, the best evidence (level 2) exists for the use of IV ketamine and IV morphine for the short-term perioperative treatment of PLP and PO morphine for an intermediate to long-term treatment effect (8 weeks to 1 year). Level 2 evidence is mixed for the efficacy of perioperative epidural anesthesia with morphine and bupivacaine for short to long-term pain relief (perioperatively up to 1 year) as well as for the use of gabapentin for pain relief of intermediate duration (6 weeks).
根据目前对这种疾病病理生理学的理解,回顾治疗幻肢痛(PLP)的当前基于证据的药理学治疗方法。
我们对专门研究 PLP 药物治疗的原始研究论文进行了系统综述。文献来源于 PubMed、Embase、Scopus 和 Cochrane 对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL)。排除了动物研究、“神经病理性”而非“幻肢”疼痛或没有疼痛评分和/或功能测量作为主要结果的研究。对个别治疗方法给予了证据水平 1-4。这些水平包括荟萃分析或系统评价(水平 1)、一项或多项充分有力的随机对照试验(水平 2)、回顾性研究、开放标签试验、试点研究(水平 3)和轶事、病例报告或临床经验(水平 4)。
我们发现了关于加巴喷丁(口服[PO]和静脉[IV]吗啡、曲马多、肌肉内[IM]肉毒毒素、IV 和硬膜外氯胺酮)的 2 级证据,阿米替林、右美沙芬、托吡酯、IV 降钙素、PO 美金刚、连续外周神经导管镇痛用罗哌卡因的 3 级证据,以及美沙酮、鞘内[IT]丁丙诺啡、IT 和硬膜外芬太尼、度洛西汀、氟西汀、米氮平、氯硝西泮、米那普仑、辣椒素和普瑞巴林的 4 级证据。
目前,关于短期围手术期治疗 PLP 的 IV 氯胺酮和 IV 吗啡以及中期至长期治疗效果的 PO 吗啡(8 周至 1 年),最佳证据(2 级)存在。围手术期硬膜外麻醉用吗啡和布比卡因的短期至长期镇痛效果(围手术期长达 1 年)以及加巴喷丁用于中度持续时间镇痛的疗效(6 周)的 2 级证据存在差异。