Sousa Inês, Vilela Pedro, Figueiredo Patrícia
Institute for Systems and Robotics, Lisbon, Portugal; Department of Bioengineering, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal; Healthcare Sector, Siemens, S.A., Portugal.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2014 Dec;40(6):1453-62. doi: 10.1002/jmri.24493. Epub 2013 Nov 13.
To evaluate the reproducibility of estimation of cerebral blood flow (CBF), bolus arrival time (BAT), and arterial blood volume (aBV) from arterial spin labeling (ASL) data acquired at multiple postlabeling delays (PLDs).
CBF, BAT, and aBV parameters were estimated from flow-suppressed and nonflow-suppressed multiple-PDL PICORE-Q2TIPS ASL using model-based Bayesian and least-squares fitting frameworks, and aBV was also obtained from a model-free approach. Reproducibility of these parameters was assessed by computing the within- and between-subject coefficients of variability (CVw and CVb).
CVw and CVb were comparable across model-based approaches, but were greater for the aBV from the model-free approach. Overall, the Bayesian model estimation procedure was found to provide the best compromise between reliability and reproducibility, yielding CVw/CVb values of 21/21, 3/4, and 24/26% for CBF, BAT, and aBV, respectively. Although a CBF range of 45 mL/100g/min to 59 mL/100g/min was found on average and a BAT of 0.7-1.0 seconds across methods, the corresponding maps were comparable in terms of the parameters' spatial distributions, and in particular in the identification of macrovascular locations, as assessed through comparison with time-of-flight images.
Reproducible estimates of CBF, BAT, and aBV values can be obtained from non-macroflow-suppressed ASL using both least-squares and Bayesian model-based methods.
评估在多个标记后延迟(PLD)下采集的动脉自旋标记(ASL)数据对脑血流量(CBF)、团注到达时间(BAT)和动脉血容量(aBV)估计的可重复性。
使用基于模型的贝叶斯和最小二乘拟合框架,从血流抑制和非血流抑制的多PLD PICORE-Q2TIPS ASL估计CBF、BAT和aBV参数,并且aBV也通过无模型方法获得。通过计算受试者内和受试者间变异系数(CVw和CVb)来评估这些参数的可重复性。
基于模型的方法之间CVw和CVb相当,但无模型方法得出的aBV的CVw和CVb更大。总体而言,发现贝叶斯模型估计程序在可靠性和可重复性之间提供了最佳折衷,CBF、BAT和aBV的CVw/CVb值分别为21/21%、3/4%和24/26%。尽管各方法平均发现CBF范围为45 mL/100g/min至59 mL/100g/min且BAT为0.7 - 1.0秒,但相应的图谱在参数的空间分布方面具有可比性,特别是在大血管位置的识别方面,通过与飞行时间图像比较进行评估。
使用最小二乘法和基于贝叶斯模型的方法,可从非大血流抑制的ASL获得CBF、BAT和aBV值的可重复估计。