Noone Damien, Waters Aoife, Pluthero Fred G, Geary Denis F, Kirschfink Michael, Zipfel Peter F, Licht Christoph
Division of Nephrology, The Hospital for Sick Children, 555 University Avenue, Toronto, ON, M5G 1X8, Canada.
Pediatr Nephrol. 2014 May;29(5):841-51. doi: 10.1007/s00467-013-2654-x. Epub 2013 Nov 20.
Deficiency of complement factor H-related (CFHR) proteins and CFH autoantibody-positive hemolytic uremic syndrome (DEAP-HUS) represents a unique subgroup of complement-mediated atypical HUS (aHUS). Autoantibodies to the C-terminus of CFH block CFH surface recognition and mimic mutations found in the genetic form of (CFH-mediated) aHUS. CFH autoantibodies are found in 10-15 % of aHUS patients and occur--so far unexplained--almost exclusively in the background of CFHR1 or CFHR3/CFHR1 deletions.
As a well-defined role for eculizumab in the treatment of complement-mediated aHUS is becoming established, its role in DEAP-HUS is less conspicuous, where a B-cell-depleting and immunosuppressive treatment strategy is being proposed in the literature.
We here show eculizumab to be safe and effective in maintaining a disease-free state, without recurrence, in a previously plasma-therapy-dependent DEAP-HUS patient, and in another patient in whom, although showing a good clinical response to plasma therapy, the therapy was hampered by allergic reactions to fresh frozen plasma and contend there is a rationale for the use of eculizumab in concert with an immunosuppressive strategy in the treatment of DEAP-HUS. Considering the high rate of early relapse, the possible coexistence and contribution of both known and unknown complement-gene mutations, the probable pathogenic role of CFHR1 as a complement alternative pathway (CAP) regulator, the experimental nature of measuring and using anti-CFH autoantibodies to guide management, and until the positive reports of immunosuppression in addition to plasma therapy are confirmed in prospective studies, we feel that a complement-directed therapy should not be neglected in DEAP-HUS. Serial CFH autoantibody titer testing may become a valuable tool to monitor treatment response, and weaning patients off eculizumab may become an option once CFH autoantibody levels are depleted.
A prospective study of eculizumab treatment in a larger cohort of DEAP-HUS patients is required to validate the applicability of our positive experience.
补体因子H相关(CFHR)蛋白缺乏和CFH自身抗体阳性溶血性尿毒症综合征(DEAP-HUS)是补体介导的非典型溶血性尿毒症综合征(aHUS)的一个独特亚组。针对CFH C末端的自身抗体可阻断CFH的表面识别,并模拟(CFH介导的)aHUS遗传形式中发现的突变。10%-15%的aHUS患者存在CFH自身抗体,且几乎仅在CFHR1或CFHR3/CFHR1缺失的背景下出现,其原因至今不明。
随着依库珠单抗在治疗补体介导的aHUS中的明确作用逐渐确立,其在DEAP-HUS中的作用尚不明显,文献中提出了一种B细胞清除和免疫抑制治疗策略。
我们在此表明,依库珠单抗在一名先前依赖血浆治疗的DEAP-HUS患者以及另一名虽对血浆治疗有良好临床反应但因对新鲜冰冻血浆过敏而使治疗受阻的患者中,在维持无病状态且无复发方面是安全有效的,并认为在DEAP-HUS治疗中联合免疫抑制策略使用依库珠单抗是有理论依据的。考虑到早期复发率高、已知和未知补体基因突变可能并存及作用、CFHR1作为补体替代途径(CAP)调节剂可能的致病作用、测量和使用抗CFH自身抗体指导治疗的实验性质,以及在前瞻性研究证实血浆治疗之外免疫抑制的阳性报告之前,我们认为在DEAP-HUS中不应忽视补体导向治疗。连续检测CFH自身抗体滴度可能成为监测治疗反应的有价值工具,一旦CFH自身抗体水平降低,使患者停用依库珠单抗可能成为一种选择。
需要对更大队列的DEAP-HUS患者进行依库珠单抗治疗的前瞻性研究,以验证我们的阳性经验的适用性。