O'Connor Jean E, Coyle Joseph, Bogue Conor, Spence Liam D, Last Jason
UCD School of Medicine and Medical Science, Health Sciences Centre, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland.
Department of Radiology, Cork University Hospital, Wilton, Cork, Ireland.
Forensic Sci Int. 2014 Jan;234:188.e1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2013.10.032. Epub 2013 Oct 31.
Age estimation in living subjects is primarily achieved through assessment of a hand-wrist radiograph and comparison with a standard reference atlas. Recently, maturation of other regions of the skeleton has also been assessed in an attempt to refine the age estimates. The current study presents a method to predict bone age directly from the knee in a modern Irish sample. Ten maturity indicators (A-J) at the knee were examined from radiographs of 221 subjects (137 males; 84 females). Each indicator was assigned a maturity score. Scores for indicators A-G, H-J and A-J, respectively, were totalled to provide a cumulative maturity score for change in morphology of the epiphyses (AG), epiphyseal union (HJ) and the combination of both (AJ). Linear regression equations to predict age from the maturity scores (AG, HJ, AJ) were constructed for males and females. For males, equation-AJ demonstrated the greatest predictive capability (R(2)=0.775) while for females equation-HJ had the strongest capacity for prediction (R(2)=0.815). When equation-AJ for males and equation-HJ for females were applied to the current sample, the predicted age of 90% of subjects was within ±1.5 years of actual age for male subjects and within +2.0 to -1.9 years of actual age for female subjects. The regression formulae and associated charts represent the most contemporary method of age prediction currently available for an Irish population, and provide a further technique which can contribute to a multifactorial approach to age estimation in non-adults.
活体受试者的年龄估计主要通过对手腕部X光片进行评估并与标准参考图谱进行比较来实现。最近,人们也开始评估骨骼其他部位的成熟度,以期完善年龄估计。本研究提出了一种直接根据现代爱尔兰样本的膝盖来预测骨龄的方法。从221名受试者(137名男性;84名女性)的X光片中检查了膝盖处的10个成熟度指标(A - J)。每个指标都被赋予了一个成熟度分数。分别将指标A - G、H - J和A - J的分数相加,以得出骨骺形态变化(AG)、骨骺联合(HJ)以及两者结合(AJ)的累积成熟度分数。针对男性和女性构建了根据成熟度分数(AG、HJ、AJ)预测年龄的线性回归方程。对于男性,方程 - AJ显示出最大的预测能力(R² = 0.775),而对于女性,方程 - HJ的预测能力最强(R² = 0.815)。当将男性的方程 - AJ和女性的方程 - HJ应用于当前样本时,90%受试者的预测年龄与男性实际年龄相差在±1.5岁以内,与女性实际年龄相差在实际年龄加2.0岁至减1.9岁以内。这些回归公式和相关图表代表了目前爱尔兰人群中最现代的年龄预测方法,并提供了另一种技术,可有助于采用多因素方法对非成年人进行年龄估计。