Karolinska Institutet at Department of Cardiology, Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden.
Scand Cardiovasc J. 2014 Feb;48(1):35-40. doi: 10.3109/14017431.2013.859296. Epub 2013 Nov 22.
Pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) is an established method for treatment of drug refractory atrial fibrillation. The aim of this study was to evaluate whether a more active regular supply of analgesic and sedative drugs reduces pain and discomfort. We also wanted to evaluate gender differences in pain perception and to compare standard radiofrequency (RF) with cryo balloon ablation (Cryo) from this perspective.
A total of 80 patients, 40 men, median age 58 (range 23-76) years, who underwent PVI under conscious sedation were studied. They were randomized to either standard treatment with morphine and diazepam (control group, C) or to a more active analgesic strategy (A) with pre-medication with oral midazolam mixture and intravenous alfentanil and midazolam regularly administrated during the procedure. Forty patients were treated with RF and 40 with Cryo.
The majority of the patients experienced pain during the procedure. The maximal pain assessed with numerical rating scale (NRS), was lower in the active group compared with that in controls (p = 0.02). Women experienced more pain than men (p = 0.01). RF was more painful than Cryo (p < 0.001).
An active regular supply of analgesic and sedative drugs reduce pain and discomfort during PVI. Women experience more pain than men during this procedure and PVI performed with Cryo is less painful than with RF.
肺静脉隔离(PVI)是治疗药物难治性心房颤动的一种已确立的方法。本研究旨在评估更积极的常规镇痛和镇静药物供应是否能减轻疼痛和不适。我们还想评估疼痛感知方面的性别差异,并从这一角度比较标准射频(RF)与冷冻球囊消融(Cryo)。
共 80 名男性患者(中位年龄 58 岁,范围 23-76 岁),在清醒镇静下接受 PVI 治疗,他们被随机分为接受吗啡和地西泮标准治疗(对照组,C)或接受更积极的镇痛策略(A),即术前给予口服咪达唑仑混合物和静脉注射阿芬太尼,在手术过程中定期给予咪达唑仑。40 例患者接受 RF 治疗,40 例患者接受 Cryo 治疗。
大多数患者在手术过程中感到疼痛。用数字评分量表(NRS)评估的最大疼痛在积极组低于对照组(p=0.02)。女性比男性感到更疼痛(p=0.01)。RF 比 Cryo 更痛(p<0.001)。
积极定期给予镇痛和镇静药物可减轻 PVI 过程中的疼痛和不适。女性在该过程中比男性感到更疼痛,并且 Cryo 进行的 PVI 比 RF 更不痛。