Department of Radiation Oncology, University Medical Center Mannheim, University of Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany.
Radiat Oncol. 2013 Nov 27;8:276. doi: 10.1186/1748-717X-8-276.
Evaluation of dose escalated salvage radiotherapy (SRT) in patients after radical prostatectomy (RP) who had never received antihormonal therapy. To investigate prognostic factors of the outcome of SRT and to analyze which patient subsets benefit most from dose escalation.
Between 2002 and 2008, 76 patients were treated in three different dose-groups: an earlier cohort treated with 66 Gy irrespective of pre-RT-characteristics and two later cohorts treated with 70 Gy or 75 Gy depending on pre-RT-characteristics. Biochemical-relapse-free-survival (bRFS), clinical-relapse-free-survival (cRFS) and late toxicity were evaluated.
Four-year bRFS and cRFS were 62.5% and 85%. Gleason score <8, positive surgical resection margin (PSRM) and low PSA (≤0.5 ng/ml) before SRT resulted in higher bRFS. Analysis of the whole group showed no clear dose-outcome relationship. Patients with PSRM, however, had improved bRFS when escalating >66 Gy. While > 70 Gy did not improve the overall results, 4-year bRFS for patients with manifest local recurrence in the high-dose group was still comparable to those without manifest local recurrences. No grade 4 and minimal grade 3 gastrointestinal and urinary toxicity were observed.
Dose-escalated SRT achieves high biochemical control. The data strongly support the application of at least 70 Gy rather than 66 Gy. They do not prove positive effects of doses >70 Gy but do not disprove them as these doses were only applied to an unfavorable patients selection.
评估根治性前列腺切除术(RP)后从未接受过抗激素治疗的患者进行挽救性放疗(SRT)剂量递增的效果。探讨 SRT 结果的预后因素,并分析哪些患者亚组最受益于剂量递增。
2002 年至 2008 年间,76 例患者分为三个不同剂量组:一组为 66Gy 组,不论放疗前的特征如何,都给予 66Gy 的剂量;两组分别给予 70Gy 或 75Gy 的剂量,取决于放疗前的特征。评估生化无复发生存(bRFS)、临床无复发生存(cRFS)和晚期毒性。
4 年 bRFS 和 cRFS 分别为 62.5%和 85%。SRT 前 Gleason 评分<8、手术切缘阳性(PSRM)和 PSA 低(≤0.5ng/ml)与较高的 bRFS 相关。对整个组的分析表明,没有明确的剂量-结果关系。但是,有 PSRM 的患者在给予>66Gy 时,bRFS 得到改善。虽然>70Gy 并没有改善整体结果,但高剂量组中出现明显局部复发的患者的 4 年 bRFS 仍与无明显局部复发的患者相当。未观察到 4 级和最小 3 级胃肠道和泌尿系统毒性。
递增剂量的 SRT 可实现高生化控制。这些数据强烈支持应用至少 70Gy,而不是 66Gy。它们不能证明>70Gy 的剂量有积极影响,但也不能否定这些剂量,因为这些剂量仅应用于不利的患者选择。