Byun Soo-Yong, Schofer Evan, Kim Kyung-Keun
The Pennsylvania State University.
Sociol Educ. 2012 Jul 1;85(3). doi: 10.1177/0038040712447180.
The concept of cultural capital has proved invaluable in understanding educational systems in Western countries, and recent work seeks to extend those insights to the diverse educational systems of other geographic regions. We explored cultural capital in South Korea by investigating the relationships among family socioeconomic status (SES), cultural capital, and children's academic achievement using data from the 2000 Programme for International Student Assessment. South Korea was compared with Japan, France, and the United States to understand how institutional features of South Korean education shape the role of cultural capital in academic success. Results showed that family SES had a positive effect on both parental objectified cultural capital and children's embodied cultural capital in South Korea, consistent with evidence from the other countries. Moreover, parental objectified cultural capital had a positive effect on children's academic achievement in South Korea. In contrast to other countries, however, children's embodied cultural capital had a negative effect on academic achievement in South Korea controlling for the other variables. We highlighted several institutional features of South Korean education including a standardized curriculum, extreme focus on test preparation, and extensive shadow education, which may combine to suppress the effect of children's embodied cultural capital on academic achievement.
文化资本的概念在理解西方国家的教育体系方面已被证明具有极高价值,近期的研究试图将这些见解扩展到其他地理区域多样的教育体系中。我们利用2000年国际学生评估项目的数据,通过调查家庭社会经济地位(SES)、文化资本和儿童学业成绩之间的关系,对韩国的文化资本进行了探究。将韩国与日本、法国和美国进行比较,以了解韩国教育的制度特征如何塑造文化资本在学业成功中的作用。结果显示,在韩国,家庭社会经济地位对父母的客观化文化资本和儿童的具体化文化资本均有积极影响,这与其他国家的证据一致。此外,在韩国,父母的客观化文化资本对儿童的学业成绩有积极影响。然而,与其他国家不同的是,在控制其他变量的情况下,韩国儿童的具体化文化资本对学业成绩有负面影响。我们强调了韩国教育的几个制度特征,包括标准化课程、极度注重考试准备以及广泛的课外辅导,这些因素可能共同抑制了儿童具体化文化资本对学业成绩的影响。