1University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2014 May;28(4):377-86. doi: 10.1177/1545968313513073. Epub 2013 Dec 6.
A recent Cochrane Review showed that early robotic training of the upper limb in stroke survivors can be more effective than other interventions when improving activities of daily living involving the arm function is the aim of therapy.
We tested for efficacy of the study a protocol which involved the use of the NeReBot therapy in partial substitution of standard upper limb rehabilitation in post-acute stroke patients.
In this dose-matched, randomized controlled clinical trial, 34 hemiparetic participants with movement against gravity in shoulder, elbow, and wrist muscle groups were enrolled within 15 days of the onset of stroke. All participants received a total daily rehabilitation treatment for 120 minutes, 5 days per week for 5 weeks. The control group received standard therapy for the upper limb. The experimental group received standard therapy (65% of exercise time) associated with robotic training (35% of exercise time). Muscle tone (Modified Ashworth Scale), strength (Medical Research Council), and synergism (Fugl-Meyer motor scores) were measured at impairment level, whereas dexterity (Box and Block Test and Frenchay Arm Test) and activities of daily living (Functional Independence Measure) were measured at activity level. All assessments were performed at baseline, at the end of therapy (time T1), at 3 months (time T2), and at 7 months (time T3) after entry. All between-group analyses were tested using nonparametric test with Bonferroni's adjustments for multiple testing.
No significant between-group differences were found with respect to demographic characteristics, motor, dexterity, and ADLs at baseline, postintervention (T1) and at follow-up (T2 and T3).
The robot therapy by NeReBot did not lead to better outcomes compared with conventional inpatient rehabilitation.
最近的一项 Cochrane 综述表明,在脑卒中幸存者中,早期进行上肢机器人训练在改善涉及手臂功能的日常生活活动方面可能比其他干预措施更有效,这是治疗的目的。
我们测试了该研究方案的疗效,该方案涉及在部分替代急性脑卒中后患者的常规上肢康复治疗中使用 NeReBot 治疗。
在这项剂量匹配、随机对照临床试验中,34 名偏瘫患者在脑卒中发病后 15 天内被招募,这些患者在肩、肘和腕肌肉群中有对抗重力的运动。所有参与者均接受每天 120 分钟、每周 5 天、共 5 周的总康复治疗。对照组接受常规上肢治疗,实验组接受常规治疗(运动时间的 65%)和机器人训练(运动时间的 35%)。在损伤水平测量肌肉张力(改良 Ashworth 量表)、力量(医学研究委员会)和协同作用(Fugl-Meyer 运动评分),在活动水平测量灵巧度(Box 和 Block 测试和 Frenchay 上肢测试)和日常生活活动能力(功能性独立测量)。所有评估均在基线时、治疗结束时(时间 T1)、3 个月(时间 T2)和 7 个月(时间 T3)后进行。所有组间分析均采用非参数检验,并采用 Bonferroni 多重检验调整进行检验。
在基线、干预后(T1)和随访(T2 和 T3)时,两组间在人口统计学特征、运动、灵巧度和 ADLs 方面均无显著差异。
与常规住院康复治疗相比,NeReBot 机器人治疗并未带来更好的结果。