AlterSanté, Centre Hospitalier de Bligny, Briis-sous-Forges, France.
Clin Infect Dis. 2014 Mar;58(5):651-9. doi: 10.1093/cid/cit806. Epub 2013 Dec 12.
Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and malaria during pregnancy cause substantial perinatal mortality. As co-trimoxazole (CMX) protects children and HIV-positive adults against malaria, we compared the effectiveness of daily CMX with sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine intermittent preventive treatment (IPT-SP) on malaria risk in HIV-positive pregnant women in a Plasmodium falciparum-endemic African area.
From January 2009 to April 2011, we included in a randomized noninferiority trial all HIV type 1-infected pregnant women (≤28 weeks' gestation, CD4 count ≥200 cells/µL, hemoglobin level ≥7 g/L) in 19 health centers in Togo. Women were randomly assigned to daily 800 mg/160 mg CMX, or IPT-SP. The primary outcome was the proportion of malaria-free pregnancies. Other outcomes included malaria incidence, parasitemia, placental malaria, anemia, and infants' birth weight.
Of 264 women randomly assigned to the CMX or IPT-SP group, 126 of 132 and 124 of 132, respectively, were included in the analysis. There were 33 confirmed cases of clinical malaria among 31 women in the CMX group, and 19 among 19 women in the IPT-SP group. Ninety-five of 126 (75.4%) women in the CMX group and 105 of 124 (84.7%) in the IPT-SP group remained malaria-free during their pregnancy (difference, 9.3%; 95% confidence interval [CI], -.53 to 19.1, not meeting the predefined noninferiority criterion). The incidence rate in intention-to-treat analysis was 108.8 malaria episodes per 100 person-years in CMX (95% CI, 105.4-112.2) and 90.1 in IPT-SP (95% CI, 86.8-93.4) (not significant). Prevalence of parasitemia was 16.7% in the CMX group vs 28% in the IPT-SP group (P = .02). Histology revealed 20.3% placental malaria in the CMX group vs. 24.6% in the IPT-SP group (not significant). Grade 3-4 anemia was more frequent in the CMX group (10% vs 4%; P = .008). No pregnant women died. Median birth weight was similar.
Daily CMX was not noninferior to IPT-SP for preventing maternal malaria but safe and at least similar regarding parasitemia or placental malaria and birth outcomes. Clinical Trials Registration ISRCTN98835811.
人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)和疟疾在孕期会导致大量围产期死亡。由于复方磺胺甲噁唑(CMX)可预防儿童和 HIV 阳性成人罹患疟疾,我们比较了 CMX 每日疗法与磺胺多辛-乙胺嘧啶间歇性预防治疗(IPT-SP)对 HIV 阳性孕妇罹患疟疾的风险。
2009 年 1 月至 2011 年 4 月,我们在多哥的 19 个卫生中心纳入所有 HIV 感染孕妇(妊娠≤28 周,CD4 计数≥200 个细胞/µL,血红蛋白水平≥7 g/L),并进行一项随机非劣效性试验。将孕妇随机分配至每日 800 mg/160 mg CMX 或 IPT-SP。主要结局为无疟疾妊娠比例。其他结局包括疟疾发病率、寄生虫血症、胎盘疟疾、贫血和婴儿出生体重。
264 例随机分配至 CMX 或 IPT-SP 组的孕妇中,分别有 126 例和 124 例纳入分析。CMX 组中有 31 例孕妇确诊为临床疟疾,19 例发生于 IPT-SP 组。CMX 组 126 例孕妇中有 95 例(75.4%)、IPT-SP 组 124 例孕妇中有 105 例(84.7%)在孕期无疟疾(差异,9.3%;95%置信区间[CI],-.53 至 19.1,未达到预先设定的非劣效性标准)。意向治疗分析中 CMX 组的疟疾发病率为 108.8 例/100 人年(95%CI,105.4-112.2),IPT-SP 组为 90.1 例/100 人年(95%CI,86.8-93.4)(无统计学差异)。CMX 组寄生虫血症患病率为 16.7%,IPT-SP 组为 28%(P=0.02)。组织学检查显示,CMX 组胎盘疟疾发生率为 20.3%,IPT-SP 组为 24.6%(无统计学差异)。CMX 组 3-4 级贫血更为常见(10%比 4%;P=0.008)。无孕妇死亡。中位出生体重相似。
CMX 每日疗法与 IPT-SP 相比,预防孕妇疟疾的非劣效性不成立,但在寄生虫血症或胎盘疟疾和分娩结局方面是安全的,且至少相似。
ISRCTN81655555。