Center on Aging, School of Nursing, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
BMC Geriatr. 2013 Dec 19;13:137. doi: 10.1186/1471-2318-13-137.
This study compared individuals whose clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease (AD) matched or did not match neuropathologic results at autopsy on clinical and functional outcomes (cognitive impairment, functional status and neuropsychiatric symptoms). The study also assessed the extent of potentially inappropriate medication use (using potentially unnecessary medications or potentially inappropriate prescribing) among misdiagnosed patients.
Longitudinal data from the National Alzheimer's Coordinating Center Uniform Data Set (NACC-UDS, 2005-2010) and corresponding NACC neuropathological data were utilized to compare 88 misdiagnosed and 438 accurately diagnosed patients.
Following adjustment of sociodemographic characteristics, the misdiagnosed were found to have less severe cognitive and functional impairment. However, after statistical adjustment for sociodemographics, dementia severity level, time since onset of cognitive decline and probable AD diagnosis at baseline, the groups significantly differed on only one outcome: the misdiagnosed were less likely to be depressed/dysphoric. Among the misdiagnosed, 18.18% were treated with potentially inappropriate medication. An additional analysis noted this rate could be as high as 67.10%.
Findings highlight the importance of making an accurate AD diagnosis to help reduce unnecessary treatment and increase appropriate therapy. Additional research is needed to demonstrate the link between potentially inappropriate treatment and adverse health outcomes in misdiagnosed AD patients.
本研究比较了临床诊断为阿尔茨海默病(AD)的个体与尸检时神经病理学结果相符或不符的个体在临床和功能结局(认知障碍、功能状态和神经精神症状)方面的差异。该研究还评估了误诊患者中潜在不适当用药(使用不必要的药物或不适当的处方)的程度。
利用国家阿尔茨海默病协调中心统一数据集(NACC-UDS,2005-2010 年)和相应的 NACC 神经病理学数据进行了纵向数据分析,比较了 88 名误诊和 438 名准确诊断的患者。
在调整社会人口统计学特征后,发现误诊组的认知和功能障碍程度较轻。然而,在对社会人口统计学、痴呆严重程度、认知衰退开始时间和基线时可能的 AD 诊断进行统计调整后,仅在一个结果上两组存在显著差异:误诊组不太可能出现抑郁/情绪低落。在误诊组中,有 18.18%的患者接受了潜在不适当的药物治疗。进一步的分析表明,这一比例可能高达 67.10%。
研究结果强调了做出准确的 AD 诊断的重要性,以帮助减少不必要的治疗和增加适当的治疗。需要进一步研究以证明误诊 AD 患者中潜在不适当治疗与不良健康结局之间的联系。