van Doorn Evert A, van Kleef Gerben A, van der Pligt Joop
Department of Social Psychology, University of Amsterdam.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2014 Jun;143(3):980-4. doi: 10.1037/a0035226. Epub 2013 Dec 23.
How do instructors' emotional expressions influence students' learning performance? Scholars and practitioners alike have emphasized the importance of positive, nurturing emotions for successful learning. However, teachers may sometimes lose their temper and express anger at their pupils. Drawing on emotions as social information (EASI) theory, we hypothesized that expressions of anger can benefit learning performance. In Experiment 1, participants who were confronted with an angry instructor exhibited more accurate recognition of word pairs after a week of learning, compared with those who were confronted with a happy instructor. In Experiment 2, we conceptually replicated this effect on a recall task, but only among participants in a promotion rather than prevention focus. Present findings thus show, for the 1st time, that instructor anger can enhance students' performance. Findings are consistent with a conceptualization of emotion as social information and call into question the generally endorsed positivity paradigm.
教师的情绪表达如何影响学生的学习成绩?学者和从业者都强调了积极、滋养性情绪对成功学习的重要性。然而,教师有时可能会发脾气并对学生表达愤怒。基于情绪即社会信息(EASI)理论,我们假设愤怒的表达可能有益于学习成绩。在实验1中,与面对一位开心的教师的参与者相比,面对一位愤怒教师的参与者在经过一周的学习后对单词对的识别更准确。在实验2中,我们在一项回忆任务上从概念上重复了这一效应,但仅在处于促进而非预防焦点的参与者中。因此,目前的研究首次表明,教师的愤怒可以提高学生的成绩。研究结果与将情绪概念化为社会信息的观点一致,并对普遍认可的积极范式提出了质疑。