Forbes Patrick A, Dakin Christopher J, Geers Anoek M, Vlaar Martijn P, Happee Riender, Siegmund Gunter P, Schouten Alfred C, Blouin Jean-Sébastien
Department of Biomechanical Engineering, Faculty of Mechanical, Maritime and Materials Engineering, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands.
School of Kinesiology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
PLoS One. 2014 Jan 2;9(1):e84385. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0084385. eCollection 2014.
Electrical vestibular stimulation is often used to assess vestibulo-motor and postural responses in both clinical and research settings. Stochastic vestibular stimulation (SVS) is a recently established technique with many advantages over its square-wave counterpart; however, the evoked muscle responses remain relatively small. Although the vestibular-evoked responses can be enhanced by increasing the stimulus amplitude, subjects often perceive these higher intensity electrical stimuli as noxious or painful. Here, we developed multisine vestibular stimulation (MVS) signals that include precise frequency contributions to increase signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) of stimulus-evoked muscle and motor responses. Subjects were exposed to three different MVS stimuli to establish that: 1) MVS signals evoke equivalent vestibulo-motor responses compared to SVS while improving subject comfort and reducing experimentation time, 2) stimulus-evoked vestibulo-motor responses are reliably estimated as a linear system and 3) specific components of the cumulant density time domain vestibulo-motor responses can be targeted by controlling the frequency content of the input stimulus. Our results revealed that in comparison to SVS, MVS signals increased the SNR 3-6 times, reduced the minimum experimentation time by 85% and improved subjective measures of comfort by 20-80%. Vestibulo-motor responses measured using both EMG and force were not substantially affected by nonlinear distortions. In addition, by limiting the contribution of high frequencies within the MVS input stimulus, the magnitude of the medium latency time domain motor output response was increased by 58%. These results demonstrate that MVS stimuli can be designed to target and enhance vestibulo-motor output responses while simultaneously improving subject comfort, which should prove beneficial for both research and clinical applications.
在临床和研究环境中,电前庭刺激常用于评估前庭运动和姿势反应。随机前庭刺激(SVS)是一种最近建立的技术,与方波刺激相比有许多优点;然而,诱发的肌肉反应仍然相对较小。尽管可以通过增加刺激幅度来增强前庭诱发反应,但受试者通常会将这些更高强度的电刺激视为有害或疼痛的。在这里,我们开发了多正弦前庭刺激(MVS)信号,其包括精确的频率成分,以提高刺激诱发的肌肉和运动反应的信噪比(SNR)。让受试者暴露于三种不同的MVS刺激下,以确定:1)与SVS相比,MVS信号诱发同等的前庭运动反应,同时提高受试者的舒适度并减少实验时间;2)刺激诱发的前庭运动反应可作为线性系统可靠地估计;3)通过控制输入刺激的频率成分,可以靶向累积密度时域前庭运动反应的特定成分。我们的结果表明,与SVS相比,MVS信号使信噪比提高了3至6倍,将最短实验时间减少了85%,并将舒适度的主观测量提高了20%至80%。使用肌电图和力量测量的前庭运动反应基本上不受非线性失真的影响。此外,通过限制MVS输入刺激中高频成分的贡献,中潜伏期时域运动输出反应的幅度增加了58%。这些结果表明,MVS刺激可以设计成靶向并增强前庭运动输出反应,同时提高受试者的舒适度,这对研究和临床应用都应是有益的。