Li D, Sinclair A J, Mann N J, Turner A, Ball M J
School of Health Sciences, Deakin University, 336 Glenferrie Road, Malvern, Victoria 3144, Australia.
Asia Pac J Clin Nutr. 2000 Mar;9(1):18-23. doi: 10.1046/j.1440-6047.2000.00129.x.
Dietary factors play a critical role in human health. The aim of this cross-sectional study was to examine micronutrient intake and status of subjects who were habitual meat eaters eating different quantities of meat with those who were habitual vegetarians or vegans. One hundred and thirty-nine healthy male subjects (vegan, n = 18; ovolacto-vegetarian, n = 46; moderate meat-eater, n = 65; and high meat-eater, n = 18) aged 20-55 years were recruited in metropolitan Melbourne. Each volunteer completed a semiquantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire (FFQ) and gave a fasting venous blood sample. Dietary sodium/potassium ratio was significantly lower and vitamin C, fibre and iron intakes were higher in vegetarians than in meat-eaters. High meat-eaters had a significantly higher calcium, retinol and zinc intake than did the other three dietary groups; moderate meateaters had the lowest mean intake of fibre, vitamin C and β-carotene. Vegans had a significantly higher β-carotene intake than did the other groups. Serum ferritin and vitamin B12 levels, and haemoglobin concentration were significantly lower in vegetarians than in meat-eaters. Vegans had a significantly higher serum folate concentration than did ovolacto-vegetarian and moderate meat-eater groups. There was no significant difference in serum α-tocopherol concentration. There are differences between the four diet groups that have potential to affect the subjects' health and susceptibility to chronic diseases including cardiovascular disease and cancer. Based on the present data, high meat-eaters may particularly benefit from altering their dietary pattern to reduce their sodium and saturated fat intake, and moderate meat-eaters from increasing their fibre and antioxidant consumption. Vegetarians, especially vegans, may need to increase their vitamin B12 and zinc intakes.
饮食因素对人类健康起着至关重要的作用。这项横断面研究的目的是,比较习惯食用不同量肉类的肉食者与习惯素食者或纯素食者的微量营养素摄入量和状况。在墨尔本市区招募了139名年龄在20至55岁之间的健康男性受试者(纯素食者,n = 18;蛋奶素食者,n = 46;适度肉食者,n = 65;大量肉食者,n = 18)。每位志愿者都完成了一份半定量食物频率问卷(FFQ),并提供了一份空腹静脉血样本。素食者的膳食钠/钾比显著低于肉食者,而维生素C、纤维和铁的摄入量则高于肉食者。大量肉食者的钙、视黄醇和锌摄入量明显高于其他三个饮食组;适度肉食者的纤维、维生素C和β-胡萝卜素平均摄入量最低。纯素食者的β-胡萝卜素摄入量明显高于其他组。素食者的血清铁蛋白、维生素B12水平和血红蛋白浓度明显低于肉食者。纯素食者的血清叶酸浓度明显高于蛋奶素食者和适度肉食者组。血清α-生育酚浓度无显著差异。这四个饮食组之间存在差异,这些差异可能会影响受试者的健康以及对包括心血管疾病和癌症在内的慢性疾病的易感性。根据目前的数据,大量肉食者可能特别受益于改变他们的饮食模式,以减少钠和饱和脂肪的摄入,而适度肉食者则受益于增加纤维和抗氧化剂的摄入量。素食者,尤其是纯素食者,可能需要增加维生素B12和锌的摄入量。