Division of Surgical Oncology, Department of Surgery, Nagoya, Japan.
Br J Surg. 2014 Feb;101(3):261-8. doi: 10.1002/bjs.9383. Epub 2014 Jan 8.
Right-sided hepatectomy is often selected for perihilar cholangiocarcinoma because the extrahepatic portion of the left hepatic duct is longer than that of the right hepatic duct. However, the length of resected left hepatic duct in right-sided hepatectomy has not been reported.
Patients who underwent right-sided hepatectomy for perihilar cholangiocarcinoma were reviewed retrospectively. Trisectionectomies were performed according to a previously reported technique of anatomical right hepatic trisectionectomy. Right hepatectomy was performed according to standard operative procedures. The length of resected left hepatic duct was measured.
Thirty-three patients underwent right trisectionectomy and 141 had a right hemihepatectomy. Patients having a trisectionectomy had more advanced tumours and so required combined portal vein resection more frequently. Duration of surgery and blood loss were similar in the two groups. Morbidity and mortality rates tended to be higher following hemihepatectomy than after trisectionectomy. The mean(s.d.) length of resected left hepatic duct was significantly greater in trisectionectomy than in hemihepatectomy (25·0(6·9) versus 14·8(5·3) mm; P < 0·001). In patients with Bismuth type IV tumours, the percentage of negative left hepatic duct margins was significantly higher for trisectionectomy than for hemihepatectomy (89 versus 57 per cent; P = 0·021). Achievement of R0 resection was similar and survival did not differ between the two groups, despite different tumour load.
Compared with right hemihepatectomy, anatomical right hepatic trisectionectomy provides a greater length of resected hepatic duct, leading to a high proportion of negative proximal ductal margins even in patients with Bismuth type IV tumours.
右半肝切除术常用于肝门部胆管癌,因为左肝管的肝外部分比右肝管长。然而,右半肝切除术中切除的左肝管长度尚未报道。
回顾性分析接受右半肝切除术治疗肝门部胆管癌的患者。根据先前报道的解剖性右肝三叶切除术技术行右三叶切除术。根据标准手术程序行右半肝切除术。测量切除的左肝管长度。
33 例患者行右三叶切除术,141 例行右半肝切除术。行三叶切除术的患者肿瘤更晚期,因此更常需要联合门静脉切除。两组手术时间和出血量相似。肝切除术的发病率和死亡率倾向于高于半肝切除术。三叶切除术切除的左肝管长度明显长于半肝切除术(25.0(6.9)毫米比 14.8(5.3)毫米;P<0.001)。在 Bismuth Ⅳ型肿瘤患者中,三叶切除术的左肝管切缘阴性率明显高于半肝切除术(89%比 57%;P=0.021)。尽管肿瘤负荷不同,但两组 R0 切除率相似,生存情况无差异。
与右半肝切除术相比,解剖性右肝三叶切除术可提供更长的肝管切除长度,即使在 Bismuth Ⅳ型肿瘤患者中,近端胆管切缘阴性率也较高。