Caccamo Roberta, Buracco Paolo, La Rosa Giuseppe, Cantatore Matteo, Romussi Stefano
Department for Veterinary Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Turin, Grugliasco, Italy.
BMC Vet Res. 2014 Jan 11;10:12. doi: 10.1186/1746-6148-10-12.
Forty dogs presented for brachycephalic airway obstructive syndrome with laryngeal collapse not over 1st degree (saccule eversion) underwent glottis endoscopic and radiographic skull measurements before surgery. Fifteen Pugs, fifteen French and ten English Bulldogs were included. The goals were prospectively to compare three common brachycephalic breeds for anatomical differences regarding glottis and skull measurements, and to assess if any correlation between glottis and skull measurements was present. Linear measurements were used to obtain glottis and skull indices. Correlations between glottis and skull indices and glottic measurements were evaluated. Finally, glottis indices were compared among the three breeds.
No correlation was found for glottis and skull indices. The glottic index differed among the three breeds (smaller in Pugs and higher in English Bulldogs), ultimately representing a morphologic indicator of the different larynx shape in the three breeds (more rounded in English Bulldogs, more elliptical in Pugs and in-between in French Bulldogs).
The lack of correlation between skull/glottic indices does not support skull morphology as predictor of glottic morphology. As Pugs had the lowest glottic index, it may be speculated that Pugs' original narrow glottic width may predispose to further progressive respiratory deterioration more easily than in the other two breeds.
40只患有短头气道阻塞综合征且喉塌陷不超过1级(喉囊外翻)的犬在手术前接受了声门内镜检查和颅骨X线测量。其中包括15只哈巴犬、15只法国斗牛犬和10只英国斗牛犬。目的是前瞻性地比较三种常见短头犬种在声门和颅骨测量方面的解剖学差异,并评估声门与颅骨测量之间是否存在相关性。使用线性测量来获取声门和颅骨指数。评估声门与颅骨指数及声门测量之间的相关性。最后,比较三个犬种的声门指数。
未发现声门与颅骨指数之间存在相关性。三个犬种的声门指数不同(哈巴犬较小,英国斗牛犬较高),最终代表了三个犬种不同喉部形状的形态学指标(英国斗牛犬更圆润,哈巴犬更椭圆,法国斗牛犬介于两者之间)。
颅骨/声门指数之间缺乏相关性不支持颅骨形态作为声门形态的预测指标。由于哈巴犬的声门指数最低,可以推测哈巴犬原本狭窄的声门宽度可能比其他两个犬种更容易导致进一步的进行性呼吸恶化。