Artemiou Elpida, Adams Cindy L, Toews Lorraine, Violato Claudio, Coe Jason B
J Vet Med Educ. 2014 Spring;41(1):44-54. doi: 10.3138/jvme.0913-126R.
We determined the Web-based configurations that are applied to teach medical and veterinary communication skills, evaluated their effectiveness, and suggested future educational directions for Web-based communication teaching in veterinary education. We performed a systematic search of CAB Abstracts, MEDLINE, Scopus, and ERIC limited to articles published in English between 2000 and 2012. The review focused on medical or veterinary undergraduate to clinical- or residency-level students. We selected studies for which the study population was randomized to the Web-based learning (WBL) intervention with a post-test comparison with another WBL or non-WBL method and that reported at least one empirical outcome. Two independent reviewers completed relevancy screening, data extraction, and synthesis of results using Kirkpatrick and Kirkpatrick's framework. The search retrieved 1,583 articles, and 10 met the final inclusion criteria. We identified no published articles on Web based communication platforms in veterinary medicine; however, publications summarized from human medicine demonstrated that WBL provides a potentially reliable and valid approach for teaching and assessing communication skills. Student feedback on the use of virtual patients for teaching clinical communication skills has been positive,though evidence has suggested that practice with virtual patients prompted lower relation-building responses.Empirical outcomes indicate that WBL is a viable method for expanding the approach to teaching history taking and possibly to additional tasks of the veterinary medical interview.
我们确定了用于教授医学和兽医沟通技巧的基于网络的配置,评估了它们的有效性,并为兽医教育中基于网络的沟通教学提出了未来的教育方向。我们对CAB文摘、MEDLINE、Scopus和教育资源信息中心进行了系统检索,检索范围限于2000年至2012年期间发表的英文文章。该综述聚焦于医学或兽医专业本科至临床或住院医师水平的学生。我们选择了那些研究人群被随机分配到基于网络学习(WBL)干预组,并与另一种WBL或非WBL方法进行测试后比较,且报告了至少一项实证结果的研究。两名独立评审员使用柯克帕特里克和柯克帕特里克的框架完成了相关性筛选、数据提取和结果综合。检索到1583篇文章,其中10篇符合最终纳入标准。我们未发现关于兽医学基于网络的沟通平台的已发表文章;然而,从人类医学总结的出版物表明,WBL为教授和评估沟通技巧提供了一种潜在可靠且有效的方法。学生对使用虚拟患者教授临床沟通技巧的反馈是积极的,尽管有证据表明与虚拟患者练习引发的建立关系反应较低。实证结果表明,WBL是一种可行的方法,可用于扩展病史采集教学方法,并可能扩展到兽医医学问诊的其他任务。