Hoffmann Christopher J, Chaisson Richard E, Martinson Neil A
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and Center for TB Research, Baltimore, Maryland, United States of America.
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and Center for TB Research, Baltimore, Maryland, United States of America ; Perinatal HIV Research Unit, Johannesburg, South Africa.
PLoS One. 2014 Jan 8;9(1):e83750. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0083750. eCollection 2014.
Many randomized and cohort studies have reported a survival benefit with cotrimoxazole prophylaxis without detecting a difference in tuberculosis (TB) incidence by cotrimoxazole status. However, several in vitro studies have reported that cotrimoxazole possesses anti-TB activity. We sought to compare TB incidence and TB diagnostic yield by cotrimoxazole use among participants in a well characterized cohort of HIV-infected adults living in a high TB prevalence region.
We analyzed prospective data from a long-term longitudinal cohort of adults receiving HIV care and TB investigations in Soweto, South Africa. Using longitudinal analysis, we compared total and laboratory confirmed TB incidence by cotrimoxazole status as well as all-cause mortality. In addition, we compared TB culture results by cotrimoxazole status.
In a multivariable analysis, adjusted for sex, body mass index, WHO clinical stage, time-updated CD4 count, and antiretroviral therapy status, we observed an association between cotrimoxazole and an increase in TB incidence (hazard ratio 1.7, 95% CI: 1.2, 2.2). However, when restricted to laboratory-confirmed TB, there was no association between cotrimoxazole and TB incidence (hazard ratio: 0.97, 95% CI: 0.39, 2.4). In TB cases, we found no difference in the proportion of positive sputum cultures or days to culture positivity by cotrimoxazole status. Cotrimoxazole was associated with a reduction in mortality.
In this cohort with a mortality benefit from cotrimoxazole, we found an increased risk of all TB among individuals using cotrimoxazole, likely a result of residual confounding, but no association between use of cotrimoxazole and laboratory-confirmed TB. Cotrimoxazole did not compromise TB diagnosis.
许多随机对照试验和队列研究报告称,复方新诺明预防用药可带来生存获益,但未发现其在结核病(TB)发病率方面因用药情况而存在差异。然而,多项体外研究报告称,复方新诺明具有抗结核活性。我们试图比较在结核病高流行地区生活的一组特征明确的HIV感染成人队列中,使用复方新诺明者的结核病发病率和结核病诊断率。
我们分析了南非索韦托一个接受HIV治疗和结核病调查的成人长期纵向队列的前瞻性数据。通过纵向分析,我们比较了按复方新诺明用药情况划分的结核病总发病率和实验室确诊发病率以及全因死亡率。此外,我们还比较了按复方新诺明用药情况划分的结核培养结果。
在一项多变量分析中,校正了性别、体重指数、世界卫生组织临床分期、随时间更新的CD4细胞计数和抗逆转录病毒治疗状态后,我们观察到复方新诺明与结核病发病率增加之间存在关联(风险比1.7,95%置信区间:1.2,2.2)。然而,当仅限于实验室确诊的结核病时,复方新诺明与结核病发病率之间没有关联(风险比:0.97,95%置信区间:0.39,2.4)。在结核病病例中,我们发现按复方新诺明用药情况划分,痰培养阳性比例或培养阳性天数没有差异。复方新诺明与死亡率降低有关。
在这个从复方新诺明中获得死亡率获益的队列中,我们发现使用复方新诺明的个体患所有结核病的风险增加,这可能是残余混杂因素导致的结果,但复方新诺明的使用与实验室确诊的结核病之间没有关联。复方新诺明并未影响结核病的诊断。