Columbia University, Philosophy Department, 1150 Amsterdam Avenue, 708 Philosophy Hall, New York, NY 10027, USA.
Hist Philos Life Sci. 2013;35(2):139-66.
The aim of this article is to examine the scientific and public functions of two- and three-dimensional models in the context of three episodes from nineteenth-century biology. I argue that these models incorporate both data and theory by presenting theoretical assumptions in the light of concrete data or organizing data through theoretical assumptions. Despite their diverse roles in scientific practice, they all can be characterized as mediators between data and theory. Furthermore, I argue that these different mediating functions often reflect their different audiences that included specialized scientists, students, and the general public. In this sense, models in nineteenth-century biology can be understood as mediators between theory, data, and their diverse audiences.
本文旨在通过三个来自 19 世纪生物学的案例来考察二维和三维模型的科学和公共功能。我认为,这些模型通过根据具体数据呈现理论假设或通过理论假设组织数据,将数据和理论结合在一起。尽管它们在科学实践中扮演着不同的角色,但它们都可以被描述为数据和理论之间的中介。此外,我认为这些不同的中介功能通常反映了它们不同的受众,包括专业科学家、学生和公众。从这个意义上说,19 世纪生物学中的模型可以被理解为理论、数据及其不同受众之间的中介。