Ucer T C, Botticelli D, Stavropoulos A, Mattheos N
Oaklands Hospital, Salford, UK.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2014 Mar;18 Suppl 1:52-9. doi: 10.1111/eje.12080.
Previous surveys have shown that newly graduated dentists, in most European countries, do not obtain adequate theoretical knowledge and, especially, clinical skills in implant dentistry (ID) through their undergraduate education and must therefore acquire knowledge and develop competencies through further postgraduate study. Moreover, clinicians, in general, need to continue to maintain the currency of their competence by undertaking ongoing continuing professional development (CPD). This seems particularly important in ID as techniques, and materials develop rapidly due to advances in biomedical technology. Despite recent developments, CPD in ID remains poorly organised with little standardisation or harmonisation across Europe. The objective of this survey was to explore the current status and trends within CPD education in ID in Europe.
Stakeholders and opinion leaders associated with ID education were invited by email to fill an online questionnaire (closing date: 30th April 2013). Two hundred and forty-seven questionnaires were distributed, and two separate reminders were sent to participants in 38 European countries. The survey contained 14 multiple-choice questions, and the data were collected using SurveyMonkey© software, exported in SPSS (Inc, Chicago, IL, USA) format and analysed using descriptive statistics.
Two hundred respondents working in 24 countries replied to the survey (response rate of 81% of invitees and 63% of countries surveyed). The results demonstrated a wide divergence in the content and structure of CPD in ID in Europe.
Dentists need CPD to develop their skills and to maintain their competence in ID. There is an urgent need for structured and accredited CPD, which should be readily available to all dentists practising ID. It should have pre-determined learning objectives, delivered by accredited CPD providers and educators, and have assessable outcome measures to ensure the best possible impact on clinical practice and patient safety.
先前的调查显示,在大多数欧洲国家,新毕业的牙医在本科教育中未获得足够的种植义齿学(ID)理论知识,尤其是临床技能,因此必须通过进一步的研究生学习来获取知识并培养能力。此外,一般而言,临床医生需要通过持续进行的继续职业发展(CPD)来不断保持其能力水平。这在种植义齿学领域似乎尤为重要,因为由于生物医学技术的进步,技术和材料发展迅速。尽管有近期的发展,但欧洲种植义齿学领域的继续职业发展仍组织不善,几乎没有标准化或协调统一。本次调查的目的是探索欧洲种植义齿学继续职业发展教育的现状和趋势。
通过电子邮件邀请与种植义齿学教育相关的利益相关者和意见领袖填写一份在线问卷(截止日期:2013年4月30日)。共分发了247份问卷,并向38个欧洲国家的参与者发送了两次单独的提醒。该调查包含14个多项选择题,数据使用SurveyMonkey©软件收集,以SPSS(美国伊利诺伊州芝加哥市SPSS公司)格式导出,并使用描述性统计进行分析。
来自24个国家的200名受访者回复了调查(受邀者的回复率为81%,被调查国家的回复率为63%)。结果表明,欧洲种植义齿学继续职业发展的内容和结构存在很大差异。
牙医需要通过继续职业发展来提高其种植义齿学技能并保持能力水平。迫切需要结构化且经认可的继续职业发展,所有从事种植义齿学的牙医都应能轻松获得。它应具有预先确定的学习目标,由经认可的继续职业发展提供者和教育者提供,并具有可评估的结果衡量标准,以确保对临床实践和患者安全产生尽可能好的影响。