Schweyen Ramona, Al-Nawas Bilal, Arnold Christin, Hey Jeremias
Universitätspoliklinik für Zahnärztliche Prothetik, Martin Luther Universität Halle-Wittenberg, Magdeburger Str. 16, 06112, Halle, Saale, Germany.
Universitätsklinik und Poliklinik für Mund-, Kiefer- und Gesichtschirurgie, Plastische Operationen, Johannes-Gutenberg Universität Mainz, Augustusplatz 2, 55131, Mainz, Germany.
Int J Implant Dent. 2020 Jul 8;6(1):26. doi: 10.1186/s40729-020-00224-8.
An ongoing debate in dental education is whether implant dentistry, as a multidisciplinary domain, should be integrated into the undergraduate curriculum. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the perspectives of novices, clinical educators, and experienced dentists with regard to the importance of theoretical and practical implant dentistry teaching content in undergraduate dental education. The specific objective was to determine whether a consensus could be found concerning aspects of theoretical knowledge, implant position planning, implantation, prosthetic treatment procedures, postoperative care, and prerequisite experiences that should be provided in undergraduate dental education.
A positive consensus existed in terms of theoretical education, assistance in surgical and prosthodontic procedures, implant planning and restoration in straightforward cases (i.e., posterior single crowns and bridges, overdentures on nonconnected implants), and postoperative care. A negative consensus existed for bone augmentation. Implantation was supported by novices (i.e., students and graduates). In addition, more experienced dentists were more likely to oppose implantation performed by undergraduates. The most preferred implantation method was implant insertion using a digitally fabricated drilling template, after surgical flap elevation.
Students and graduates preferred a comprehensive undergraduate education that included implant dentistry. Dentists working in private practice, and especially dentists working as university educators, were critical towards the integration of implant-related learning content into undergraduate education. The intention of medical education is to impart knowledge to students and to prepare them for life-long learning and continual professional development after graduation. Thus, an undergraduate dental curriculum that provides students a solid introduction and knowledge foundation in implant dentistry is recommended.
牙科教育中一个持续存在的争论是,作为一个多学科领域的种植牙科是否应纳入本科课程。本研究的目的是评估新手、临床教育工作者和经验丰富的牙医对于本科牙科教育中种植牙科理论和实践教学内容重要性的看法。具体目标是确定在本科牙科教育应提供的理论知识、种植体位置规划、植入、修复治疗程序、术后护理以及必备经验等方面是否能达成共识。
在理论教育、手术和修复程序中的协助、简单病例(即后牙单冠和桥、非连接种植体上的覆盖义齿)的种植规划和修复以及术后护理方面存在积极共识。在骨增量方面存在消极共识。新手(即学生和毕业生)支持植入。此外,经验更丰富的牙医更有可能反对本科生进行植入。最受欢迎的植入方法是在掀起手术瓣后使用数字制造的钻孔模板植入种植体。
学生和毕业生倾向于接受包括种植牙科的全面本科教育。私人执业牙医,尤其是大学教育工作者,对将种植相关学习内容纳入本科教育持批评态度。医学教育的目的是向学生传授知识,并使他们为毕业后的终身学习和持续专业发展做好准备。因此,建议开设一门能让学生在种植牙科方面获得扎实入门知识和基础的本科牙科课程。