Stokes Oliver M, O'Donovan Elizabeth J, Samartzis Dino, Bow Cora H, Luk Keith D K, Cheung Kenneth M C
Division of Spine Surgery, Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Duchess of Kent Children's Hospital, University of Hong Kong, 12 Sandy Bay Rd, Pokfulam, Hong Kong, SAR China.
Division of Spine Surgery, Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Duchess of Kent Children's Hospital, University of Hong Kong, 12 Sandy Bay Rd, Pokfulam, Hong Kong, SAR China.
Spine J. 2014 Oct 1;14(10):2397-404. doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2014.01.039. Epub 2014 Jan 31.
Magnetically-controlled growing rod (MCGR) technology has been reported for the treatment of early-onset scoliosis (EOS). Such technology allows for regular and frequent outpatient rod distractions without the need for additional surgery. However, pre- and postdistraction spine radiographs are required to verify the amount of lengthening. This increased exposure to ionizing radiation in developing children significantly increases their risk profile for radiation-induced cancer and noncancerous morbidity.
This study addressed the first and novel application and reliability of the use of ultrasonography, that has no ionizing radiation exposure, as an alternative to plain radiographs in the visualizing and confirming of rod distractions.
A prospective study.
Six EOS patients who underwent surgical treatment with MCGRs were prospectively recruited.
Imaging measurements based on ultrasound and plain radiographs.
All patients were imaged via ultrasound, ease of rod identification was established, and the reliability and reproducibility of optimal reference point selection assessed blindly by three individuals. The clinical algorithm, using ultrasound, was subsequently implemented. Plain radiographs served as controls.
Assessment of the rod's neck distance on ultrasound demonstrated a high degree of interrater reliability (a=0.99; p<.001). Intrarater reliability remained high on repeat measurements at different time intervals (a=1.00; p<.001). Satisfactory interrater reliability was noted when measuring the rod's neck (a=0.73; p=.010) and high reliability was noted in assessing the housing of the rod (a=0.85; p=.01) on plain radiographs. Under blinded conditions, 2 mm rod distraction measured on radiographs corresponded to 1.7 mm distraction on the ultrasound (standard deviation: 0.24 mm; p<.001). Subsequently, the clinical algorithm using ultrasound, instead of radiographs, has been successfully implemented.
This is the first study to report the use of a novel technique using noninvasive, nonionizing ultrasound to reliably document rod distractions in EOS patients. A high level of inter- and intrarater reliabilities were noted. More importantly, the use of ultrasonography may result in fewer whole spine radiographs from being taken in patients who have had MCGRs implanted for EOS; thereby decreasing their exposure to ionizing radiation and the potential risk of future radiation-induced diseases.
已有关于磁控生长棒(MCGR)技术治疗早发性脊柱侧弯(EOS)的报道。该技术可在门诊定期且频繁地进行棒体撑开,无需额外手术。然而,撑开前后需进行脊柱X线片检查以核实延长量。发育中的儿童接受电离辐射的增加显著提高了其患辐射诱发癌症和非癌性疾病的风险。
本研究探讨了超声检查在可视化和确认棒体撑开方面作为X线平片替代方法的首次创新性应用及其可靠性,超声检查无电离辐射暴露。
前瞻性研究。
前瞻性招募了6例接受MCGR手术治疗的EOS患者。
基于超声和X线平片的影像学测量。
对所有患者进行超声成像,确定棒体识别的难易程度,并由三人盲目评估最佳参考点选择的可靠性和可重复性。随后实施了使用超声的临床算法。以X线平片作为对照。
超声测量棒体颈部距离显示出高度的评分者间可靠性(α=0.99;p<0.001)。在不同时间间隔重复测量时,评分者内可靠性仍然很高(α=1.00;p<0.001)。在X线平片上测量棒体颈部时,评分者间可靠性令人满意(α=0.73;p=0.010),评估棒体外壳时可靠性较高(α=0.85;p=0.01)。在盲法条件下,X线片上测量的2mm棒体撑开对应超声上的1.7mm撑开(标准差:0.24mm;p<0.001)。随后,使用超声而非X线片的临床算法已成功实施。
这是第一项报告使用无创、非电离超声新技术可靠记录EOS患者棒体撑开情况的研究。观察到了较高水平的评分者间和评分者内可靠性。更重要的是,对于植入MCGR治疗EOS的患者,使用超声检查可能会减少全脊柱X线片的拍摄次数;从而减少他们对电离辐射的暴露以及未来辐射诱发疾病的潜在风险。