Mishra Shashikant, Bhattu Amit S, Sabnis Ravindra B, Desai Mahesh R
Department of Urology, Muljibhai Patel Urological Hospital, Nadiad, Gujarat, India.
Indian J Urol. 2014 Jan;30(1):80-3. doi: 10.4103/0970-1591.124212.
The majority of staghorn classifications do not incorporate volumetric stone burden assessment. Accurate volumetric data can easily be acquired with the ever-increasingly available computerized tomography (CT) scan. This manuscript reviews the available staghorn stone classifications and rationalizes the morphometry-based classification.
A Pubmed search was performed for articles concerning staghorn classification and morphometry. Twenty abstracts were shortlisted from a total of 43 published abstracts. In view of the paucity of manuscripts on staghorn morphometry (4), older staghorn classifications were analyzed with the aim to determine the most optimum one having relevance to the percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) monotherapy outcome.
All available staghorn classifications are limited with non-widespread applicability. The traditional partial and complete staghorn are limited due to non-descript stone volumetric data and considerable overlap of the intermediate ones in either group. A lack of standardized definition limits intergroup comparison as well. Staghorn morphometry is a recent addition to the clinical classification profiling of a staghorn calculus. It comprises extensive CT volumetric stone distribution assessment of a staghorn in a given pelvi-calyceal anatomy. It allowsmeaningful clinical classification of staghorn stones from a contemporary PCNL monotherapy perspective.
Morphometry-based classification affords clinically relevant nomenclature in predicting the outcome of PCNL for staghorn stones. Further research is required to reduce the complexity associated with measuring the volumetric stone distribution in a given calyceal system.
大多数鹿角形结石分类未纳入结石体积负荷评估。随着计算机断层扫描(CT)扫描的日益普及,准确的体积数据很容易获得。本文回顾了现有的鹿角形结石分类,并对基于形态学的分类进行了合理化分析。
在Pubmed上搜索有关鹿角形结石分类和形态学的文章。从总共43篇已发表的摘要中筛选出20篇摘要。鉴于关于鹿角形结石形态学的手稿较少(4篇),对较旧的鹿角形结石分类进行了分析,目的是确定与经皮肾镜取石术(PCNL)单一疗法结果相关的最优化分类。
所有现有的鹿角形结石分类都存在局限性,适用性不广泛。传统的部分鹿角形结石和完全鹿角形结石分类存在局限性,因为结石体积数据描述不明确,且两组中间类型有相当大的重叠。缺乏标准化定义也限制了组间比较。鹿角形结石形态学是鹿角形结石临床分类概况中的最新内容。它包括在给定肾盂肾盏解剖结构中对鹿角形结石进行广泛的CT体积分布评估。从当代PCNL单一疗法的角度来看,它能对鹿角形结石进行有意义的临床分类。
基于形态学的分类在预测PCNL治疗鹿角形结石的结果方面提供了与临床相关的命名法。需要进一步研究以降低与测量给定肾盏系统中结石体积分布相关的复杂性。