a IEL-Nutritional Epidemiology, University of Bonn, DONALD Study at the Research Institute of Child Nutrition , Dortmund , Germany.
Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2014;54(9):1140-50. doi: 10.1080/10408398.2011.627519.
A variety of genetic, mechano-response-related, endocrine-metabolic, and nutritional determinants impact bone health. Among the nutritional influences, protein intake and dietary acid load are two of the factors most controversially discussed. Although in the past high protein intake was often assumed to exert a primarily detrimental impact on bone mass and skeletal health, the majority of recent studies indicates the opposite and suggests a bone-anabolic influence. Studies examining the influence of alkalizing diets or alkalizing supplement provision on skeletal outcomes are less consistent, which raises doubts about the role of acid-base status in bone health. The present review critically evaluates relevant key issues such as acid-base terminology, influencing factors of intestinal calcium absorption, calcium balance, the endocrine-metabolic milieu related to metabolic acidosis, and some methodological aspects of dietary exposure and bone outcome examinations. It becomes apparent that for an adequate identification and characterization of either dietary acid load's or protein's impact on bone, the combined assessment of both nutritional influences is necessary.
多种遗传、力学反应相关、内分泌代谢和营养决定因素会影响骨骼健康。在营养影响中,蛋白质摄入和饮食酸负荷是两个最具争议的因素。尽管过去人们常认为高蛋白摄入对骨量和骨骼健康有主要的不利影响,但大多数最新研究表明恰恰相反,提示其具有促进骨形成的作用。研究碱性饮食或碱性补充剂对骨骼结果的影响则不太一致,这让人对酸碱状态在骨骼健康中的作用产生了怀疑。本综述批判性地评估了相关关键问题,如酸碱术语、肠道钙吸收的影响因素、钙平衡、与代谢性酸中毒相关的内分泌代谢环境以及饮食暴露和骨骼结果检查的一些方法学方面。显然,为了充分确定饮食酸负荷或蛋白质对骨骼的影响,需要同时评估这两种营养因素。