Derbyshire Katherine L, Chamberlain Samuel R, Odlaug Brian L, Schreiber Liana R N, Grant Jon E
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neuroscience, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA. E-mail:
Ann Clin Psychiatry. 2014 Feb;26(1):57-63.
Compulsive buying (CB) is a fairly common behavioral problem estimated to affect 5.8% of the population. Although previous research has examined the clinical characteristics of CB, little research has examined whether people with CB manifest cognitive deficits.
Twenty-three non-treatment-seeking compulsive buyers (mean age, 22.3±3.5; 60.9% female) and 23 age- and sex-matched healthy controls (mean age, 21.1±3.4, 60.9% female) underwent neurocognitive assessment. We predicted that the following cognitive domains would be impaired in CB: spatial working memory (Spatial Working Memory test), response inhibition (Stop-Signal Task), cognitive flexibility (Intra-Extra Dimensional Set Shift task), and decision making (Cambridge Gambling Task).
Compared with controls, individuals with CB exhibited significant impairments in response inhibition (P=.043), risk adjustment during decision making (P=.010), and spatial working memory (P=.041 total errors; P=.044 strategy scores). Deficits were of large effect size (Cohen's d, 0.6 to 1.05).
These pilot data suggest that individuals with CB experience problems in several distinct cognitive domains, supporting a likely neurobiological overlap between CB and other putative behavioral and substance addictions. These findings may have implications for shared treatment approaches as well as how we currently classify and understand CB.
强迫性购物(CB)是一个相当常见的行为问题,据估计影响着5.8%的人口。尽管先前的研究已经考察了CB的临床特征,但很少有研究考察患有CB的人是否存在认知缺陷。
23名未寻求治疗的强迫性购物者(平均年龄22.3±3.5岁;60.9%为女性)和23名年龄及性别匹配的健康对照者(平均年龄21.1±3.4岁,60.9%为女性)接受了神经认知评估。我们预测在CB中以下认知领域会受损:空间工作记忆(空间工作记忆测试)、反应抑制(停止信号任务)、认知灵活性(维度内-维度间转换任务)和决策制定(剑桥赌博任务)。
与对照组相比,患有CB的个体在反应抑制(P = 0.043)、决策过程中的风险调整(P = 0.010)和空间工作记忆(总错误数P = 0.041;策略得分P = 0.044)方面表现出显著受损。缺陷的效应量较大(科恩d值,0.6至1.05)。
这些初步数据表明,患有CB的个体在几个不同的认知领域存在问题,支持了CB与其他假定的行为和物质成瘾之间可能存在神经生物学重叠。这些发现可能对共享治疗方法以及我们目前对CB的分类和理解方式具有启示意义。