Hekmatimoghaddam Seyedhosssein, Sadeh Maryam, Khalili Mohammad Bagher, Mollaabedin Mansour, Sazmand Alireza
School of Paramedicine, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
Goodarz General Hospital, Yazd, Iran.
Pak J Biol Sci. 2013 Nov 15;16(22):1589-92. doi: 10.3923/pjbs.2013.1589.1592.
Brucellosis has long been prevalent in Iran, with considerable medical and economic importance. Timely diagnosis is needed for early management and effective prevention of its consequences in human beings and animals. Current diagnostic methods impose peculiar challenges in terms of analytical method performance. This study compares diagnostic sensitivity, specificity, predictive Value of Positive (PVP) and Predictive Value of Negative (PVN) for Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR), Wright agglutination test and blood culture used for patients suspected of brucellosis. In 120 patients clinically suspected of brucellosis and referred by physicians to the Yazd central Medical Laboratory, some relevant demographic, occupational, nutritional and clinical data were collected. Also, venous blood samples were drawn for diagnosis of brucellosis using PCR, Wright agglutination test and blood culture techniques. The most frequent symptom of patients was arthralgia (82 cases, 68.3%). PCR was positive in 25 cases (20.8%), wright test in 21 patients (17.5%) and blood culture in 6 cases (5%). In 20 out of 21 wright-positive cases, PCR was positive and all of the culture-positive patients had positive PCR. Sensitivity, specificity, PVP and PVN of blood culture compared to PCR (as the gold standard test) were 24, 100, 100 and 86%, respectively, but the above parameters when PCR is compared with blood culture (as gold standard) were 100, 83, 24 and 95%, respectively. PCR has better analytical performances than blood culture for diagnosis of brucellosis and is suitable for confirmation of Wright-positive cases.
布鲁氏菌病在伊朗长期流行,具有相当大的医学和经济重要性。为了对其在人类和动物中的后果进行早期管理和有效预防,需要及时诊断。目前的诊断方法在分析方法性能方面带来了特殊挑战。本研究比较了聚合酶链反应(PCR)、wright凝集试验和血培养用于疑似布鲁氏菌病患者时的诊断敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值(PVP)和阴性预测值(PVN)。在120例临床疑似布鲁氏菌病并由医生转诊至亚兹德中央医学实验室的患者中,收集了一些相关的人口统计学、职业、营养和临床数据。此外,采集静脉血样本,采用PCR、wright凝集试验和血培养技术诊断布鲁氏菌病。患者最常见的症状是关节痛(82例,68.3%)。PCR阳性25例(20.8%),wright试验阳性21例(17.5%),血培养阳性6例(5%)。在21例wright阳性病例中的20例中,PCR呈阳性,所有培养阳性患者的PCR均为阳性。与PCR(作为金标准检测)相比,血培养的敏感性、特异性、PVP和PVN分别为24%、100%、100%和86%,但当PCR与血培养(作为金标准)比较时,上述参数分别为100%、83%、24%和95%。在布鲁氏菌病诊断中,PCR比血培养具有更好的分析性能,适用于wright阳性病例的确诊。