Roulet Lucien, Ballereau Françoise, Hardouin Jean-Benoît, Chiffoleau Anne, Potel Gilles, Asseray Nathalie
Emergency Department, Teaching Hospital, Nantes, France; UPRES EA 3826, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Nantes, France.
UPRES EA 3826, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Nantes, France; Medqual, Teaching Hospital, Nantes, France.
J Emerg Med. 2014 Jun;46(6):857-64. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2013.11.124. Epub 2014 Feb 22.
Many adverse drug events (ADEs) are not identified by emergency physicians. Research has been done to study risk factors for ADEs and help emergency physicians diagnose ADEs. However, no research has specifically examined the causes underlying a lack of attribution of ADEs to medications in emergency department (ED) patients.
We conducted an exploratory study in a medical ED to search for the factors associated with ADE nonrecognition that are related to ED patients and ADEs.
We conducted an observational study in the medical ED of a French tertiary care hospital between January and December 2009. The study focused on all ADEs, whether or not they were related to the patient's chief complaint. ADEs were identified by an expert physician and pharmacist based on National Electronic Injury Surveillance System criteria. An ADE was considered "attributed" if any evidence of ADE suspicion, ADE diagnosis, or ADE management was documented on ED charts. Factors associated with ADE nonrecognition were identified using multiple logistic regression analysis.
Of the 465 included patients, 90 experienced an ADE at ED visit (19.4%; 95% confidence interval [CI] 15.9%-23.2%). Emergency physicians correctly recognized 36 of these cases (40.0%; 95% CI 29.8%-50.9%). On multivariate analysis, ADE nonrecognition was significantly associated with the following variables: nonrelation between the ADE and the patient's chief complaint; daily prescription of four drugs or more; and hospitalization ADE severity category.
Our results emphasize the importance of searching for ADEs in patients with daily polypharmacy or whose chief complaint does not seem to be drug related.
许多药物不良事件(ADEs)未被急诊医生识别。已有研究探讨了ADEs的风险因素,以帮助急诊医生诊断ADEs。然而,尚无研究专门探究急诊患者中ADEs未被归因于药物的潜在原因。
我们在一家急诊科进行了一项探索性研究,以寻找与ADEs未被识别相关的、与急诊患者和ADEs有关的因素。
2009年1月至12月期间,我们在一家法国三级护理医院的急诊科进行了一项观察性研究。该研究聚焦于所有ADEs,无论其是否与患者的主要诉求相关。ADEs由一名专家医生和药剂师根据国家电子伤害监测系统标准进行识别。如果急诊病历上记录了任何ADEs怀疑、诊断或处理的证据,则该ADE被视为“归因于药物”。使用多因素逻辑回归分析确定与ADEs未被识别相关的因素。
在纳入研究的465例患者中,90例在急诊就诊时发生了ADEs(19.4%;95%置信区间[CI]15.9%-23.2%)。急诊医生正确识别了其中36例(40.0%;95%CI 29.8%-50.9%)。多因素分析显示,ADEs未被识别与以下变量显著相关:ADE与患者主要诉求无关;每日服用四种或更多药物;以及住院时ADE的严重程度类别。
我们的结果强调了在每日接受多种药物治疗或主要诉求似乎与药物无关的患者中寻找ADEs的重要性。