Wallis Jennifer
Queen Mary University of London.
Hist Psychiatry. 2013 Jun;24(2):196-211. doi: 10.1177/0957154X13476200.
This article examines alienist explanations for fracture among British asylum patients in the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries. A series of deaths in asylums came to light in the 1870s which, in placing the blame for such incidents on asylum staff, called for a response from the psychiatric profession. This response drew upon other medical fields and employed novel pathological techniques to explain why fractures occurred among the insane, in many cases aligning bone fragility with particular forms of insanity (namely, General Paralysis of the Insane). Although such research aimed to provide a medical explanation for the 'fracture death', it also called into question the value of pathological research and the utility of quantitative measurement in understanding mental disease.
本文探讨了19世纪末至20世纪初英国精神病院中外籍患者骨折现象的精神病学解释。19世纪70年代,一系列精神病院死亡事件被曝光,这些事件将此类事件归咎于精神病院工作人员,这就要求精神病学界做出回应。这种回应借鉴了其他医学领域的知识,并采用了新颖的病理学技术来解释为何在精神病患者中会发生骨折,在许多情况下,将骨骼脆弱与特定形式的精神错乱(即麻痹性痴呆)联系起来。尽管此类研究旨在为“骨折死亡”提供医学解释,但它也对病理学研究的价值以及定量测量在理解精神疾病方面的实用性提出了质疑。